Canada version. Works in Canadian dollars and explains how the CRA taxes options granted from the pool: the CCPC deferral, the 110(1)(d) deduction and the $200,000 limit that skips CCPCs. US version
Option Pool Shuffle Calculator (Canada)
Size the option pool a Canadian term sheet asks for in CA$, see the effective pre-money, and how CRA rules tax the options granted from it in a CCPC.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Option Pool Shuffle Calculator?
The option pool shuffle works the same way in Canada: investors ask for an unallocated pool equal to a percentage of the fully diluted shares after the round, created before their money goes in, so the founders and existing shareholders pay for it. This version runs it in CA$, from a CA$10 million seed to a CA$36 million Series A.
What changes in Canada is how the options granted from the pool are taxed. If the company is a Canadian-controlled private corporation and the employee deals with it at arm's length, the CRA lets the employee report the option benefit in the year they sell the shares, not when they exercise. The paragraph 110(1)(d) deduction of one-half of the benefit needs, among other conditions, an exercise price no lower than the fair market value of the shares when the option was granted. And the $200,000 annual vesting limit that caps that deduction applies only to employers that are not CCPCs and have gross revenues over $500 million.
Enter the round and the pool target, and the calculator gives the new pool shares, the price per share, the effective pre-money and the headline figure that would restore your target, side by side with adding the pool after the round.
- Exact pool top-up for a post-closing pool target
- Effective pre-money and pre-money excluding the whole pool, each labelled
- Side-by-side comparison with adding the pool after the round
- Ownership points the shuffle costs existing holders
- Headline pre-money that restores your target effective valuation
- Shows when the existing pool already meets the target
Updated
How to use the Option Pool Shuffle Calculator
- Enter the headline pre-money valuation and the total investment in the round.
- Enter the fully diluted shares before the round (issued shares, granted options and the unallocated pool) and how many of them are unallocated.
- Enter the pool target from the term sheet: the unallocated pool after the round as a percent of fully diluted shares.
- Read the new pool shares, price per share and effective pre-money, then compare the two columns to see what counting the pool after the round would change.
- Use the suggested headline pre-money as a counter-offer if you accept the pool size but want the effective valuation you were aiming for.
Worked examples
A CA$12 million Series A with a 12% pool
Input
CA$36,000,000 pre-money, CA$12,000,000 investment, 12,500,000 fully diluted shares with 700,000 unallocated, 12% target
Output
1,547,619 new pool shares at CA$2.5627; effective pre-money CA$32,033,898; pre-money excluding the whole pool CA$30,240,000
Existing holders end with 63.00% instead of 65.04% with the pool added after the round, 2.04 points. A headline of CA$40,254,545 with the same pool would leave an effective CA$36 million. The pool is worth CA$5,760,000 at the round price.
A seed round with a 10% pool
Input
CA$10,000,000 pre-money, CA$2,500,000 investment, 10,000,000 fully diluted shares with 400,000 unallocated, 10% target
Output
971,429 new pool shares at CA$0.9115; effective pre-money CA$9,114,583
The shuffle costs existing holders 1.40 points (70.00% against 71.40%). Options later granted from this pool at an exercise price no lower than fair market value at grant can qualify for the 110(1)(d) deduction.
Background and insight
Term sheets usually require that, after the closing, an unallocated pool equal to a set percentage of the fully diluted shares is available for future grants, and that the pool is created before the financing. The NVCA model Series A term sheet writes this into its Pre-Money Valuation provision: the pre-money includes an unallocated and uncommitted employee option pool representing a stated percentage of the fully diluted post-money capitalization. Brad Feld's explanation of the price section notes that the pool size is counted in the valuation and so lowers the true pre-money valuation. Venture Hacks named it the option pool shuffle: with $2 million invested at $8 million pre and a 20% post-money pool carved from the pre-money, the founders' effective pre-money is $6 million.
The calculator solves the pool exactly. With F fully diluted shares before the round, U of them unallocated, pre-money V, investment I and target t, the new pool P must satisfy (U + P) = t × (F + P + N), where the price is V ÷ (F + P) and the investors get N = I ÷ price. That gives P = (kF − U) ÷ (1 − k) with k = t × (V + I) ÷ V; tests confirm it against an iterative solution and against Y Combinator's worked Series A example. When k reaches 1 the pool would be worth the whole pre-money and no answer exists.
Two effective figures are shown, each labelled. The effective pre-money is V minus the value of the new pool shares at the round price, which equals the value of everything that existed before the round, the old pool included; it is the same as V − (t × post-money − existing pool value). The pre-money excluding the pool also takes out the old pool, giving V − t × post-money, the value of issued shares and granted options only. The existing pool is subtracted once, in the second figure, never twice.
Common use cases
Reading a term sheet
Turn the pre-money and pool clause into the price the existing shares are really getting.
Negotiating the pool size
Show how many points of ownership each extra percent of pool costs, and back a smaller pool with a hiring plan.
Comparing two offers
Put a higher headline valuation with a bigger pool next to a lower one with a smaller pool.
Asking for a higher headline
Find the pre-money that keeps your target effective valuation with the investors' pool size.
Tips and limitations
- Set exercise prices at fair market value on the grant date. A lower price can cost employees the 110(1)(d) deduction.
- Watch CCPC status as rounds bring in non-resident investors; the deferral depends on the corporation being a CCPC when the option agreement is made.
- Count only ungranted options as the existing pool. Granted options are in the fully diluted shares but not in the pool target.
- Treat the result as a negotiating aid, not tax advice. Have an accountant check the plan and each grant.
Sources and further reading
- T4130: Employers' Guide, Taxable Benefits and Allowances, Canada Revenue Agency. Security options: 110(1)(d) conditions and one-half deduction; $200,000 limit; 110(1)(d.1) two-year rule
- Line 10100: Employment income (security options benefits), Canada Revenue Agency. Timing of the option benefit for CCPC and other employers
- Guide T4037: Capital Gains, Canada Revenue Agency. CCPC definition
Frequently asked questions
When is a stock option benefit taxed in a CCPC?
If your employer is a CCPC you deal with at arm's length, the CRA says you only report the taxable benefit for the year you sell the securities. For an employer that is not a CCPC, the benefit is generally reported in the year you exercise.
What are the conditions for the 110(1)(d) deduction?
The CRA's T4130 guide lists an agreement by a qualifying person to sell or issue the shares, arm's length dealing right after the agreement, a prescribed share, and an exercise price not less than the fair market value when the agreement was made. The employee can then deduct one-half of the taxable benefit.
Does the $200,000 limit apply to my start-up's options?
Not if the company is a CCPC. The limit applies to options granted on or after July 1, 2021 by employers that are not CCPCs and have, or belong to a group with, gross revenues of more than $500 million.
What is the 110(1)(d.1) deduction?
It applies to CCPC shares when the corporation was a CCPC when the agreement was made, the employee dealt at arm's length and held the shares for at least two years after acquiring them (except on death), and no 110(1)(d) deduction was claimed for the same benefit.
How big should a Series A pool be?
Size it from the hires you plan before the next round and their grants, then test it here. Each extra point of pool target in the pre-money is paid by the existing shareholders.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Option Pool Shuffle Calculator?
Yes. “Cap Table Dilution and the Option Pool Shuffle, Step by Step” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.