United Kingdom version. Written for UK offers: employer pension contributions above the auto-enrolment minimum, notice and restrictive covenants, salary sacrifice and benefit tax, and the day-one written statement. US version
Job Offer Evaluation Checklist (UK)
An employer pension contribution can outweigh a salary difference, and the notice period and restrictive covenants bind you long after the excitement fades.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist?
Compare the pension before the salary. A UK employer contributing well above the auto-enrolment minimum is paying you considerably more than the headline suggests, and the difference between a minimum-contribution employer and a generous one can exceed a sizeable salary gap. It is the single most commonly ignored number in a UK offer.
Then read the two clauses that bind you after the enthusiasm fades: the notice period, which constrains your next move as much as this one, and any restrictive covenants. A long notice period is a cost when you want to leave, and garden leave provisions determine whether you spend it working or waiting.
Third, the written statement of employment particulars is due on or before your first day and must cover specified minimum content. Getting the full terms before you resign from your current job, rather than after, is the order that protects you, because a verbal offer that changes on paper is a known pattern.
- Puts employer pension contributions ahead of headline salary
- Covers notice periods, garden leave and restrictive covenants
- Explains salary sacrifice and taxable benefit treatment
- Includes the day-one written statement and flexible working requests
- Tick, reword and delete items, then export as a Google Form, PDF, CSV or Markdown
Updated
How to use the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist
- Compare employer pension contributions, not just salary, since the gap can exceed a salary difference.
- Read the notice period and any restrictive covenants before accepting, not after.
- Get the full written terms before resigning, and check the probation and notice interaction.
- Price the benefits properly: what is taxable, what is salary sacrifice and what is real insurance.
- Agree flexible or hybrid arrangements in writing, and get bonus and equity terms in detail.
Worked examples
Two offers, one paying slightly more
Input
Pension section, Essentials only
Output
Employer contributions compared and the lower salary chosen
A generous employer pension contribution is deferred pay that can exceed a sizeable salary difference, and it is the number most candidates never compare.
Three-month notice period accepted casually
Input
Notice items
Output
Priced as a constraint on the next move
A long notice period binds you when you want to leave rather than when you join, and garden leave terms decide whether you work it or wait it out.
Hybrid working promised verbally
Input
Flexible items
Output
Written into the offer before accepting
Flexible working is a right to request rather than a right to have, so a cultural assurance from a manager who may leave is worth considerably less than a written term.
Offer quoted including equity
Input
Equity items
Output
Scheme, vesting, exercise price and tax treatment obtained
Without the scheme detail the equity figure is a number that may not exist in the form described, particularly where vesting cliffs and leaver provisions apply.
Background and insight
Benefits differ in value far more than they appear. Private medical insurance is usually a taxable benefit reported on a P11D, salary sacrifice arrangements for pensions, cycles and electric cars reduce taxable pay and can be genuinely valuable, and death in service cover is cheap for the employer and worth having. A list of perks is worth reading for what is taxable and what is actually insurance.
Bonus and equity terms need the detail: whether a bonus is discretionary or contractual, whether it is pro-rated, what happens if you leave before payment, and for equity whether options vest on a cliff, what the exercise price and tax treatment are, and whether the scheme is tax-advantaged such as EMI. An offer quoted with equity included and no scheme detail is quoting a number that may not exist.
Probation changes notice and sometimes benefits but does not remove statutory rights, and the written statement must state the probation terms. Where a role has a long probation with a short notice period inside it, that is a risk worth pricing rather than ignoring.
Flexible working is a right to request rather than a right to have, with the employer required to deal with a request in a reasonable manner and within a statutory period, and requests can be made from day one. Agreeing hybrid or flexible terms in writing in the offer is far stronger than relying on a cultural assurance from a manager who may move.
For pay progression, the useful questions are how pay is reviewed and when, what the band is for the role, whether there is a bonus pool and how it was distributed last year, and what happened to the last person in the job. Those are harder to answer with platitudes than questions about culture.
On the employer side of diligence, Companies House filings show the financial position of a private company, which matters for a small employer offering equity or a long notice period, and a quick search for employment tribunal judgments is a legitimate and under-used check.
Finally the practical risk: do not resign until you have the written offer, references cleared and any right to work or background check completed, because offers are routinely conditional and a resignation cannot be withdrawn.
Common use cases
Comparing two offers
Pension contributions and total value.
Before resigning
Written terms, conditions and checks cleared.
Clauses that bind you
Notice, covenants and garden leave.
Benefits and equity
What is taxable, insured or hypothetical.
Tips and limitations
- Compare pension contributions first. It is the biggest hidden number.
- A long notice period is a cost to you, not to them.
- Get hybrid terms in writing; a manager’s assurance moves with the manager.
- Ask whether the bonus is discretionary or contractual.
- Never resign before the written offer and all conditions are cleared.
Sources and further reading
- Workplace pensions, UK Government. Auto-enrolment minimums and employer contributions
- Employment contracts and conditions, UK Government. Written statement content and probation terms
- Notice periods, Acas. Statutory notice, garden leave and pay in lieu
- Expenses and benefits for employers, UK Government. Taxable benefits and salary sacrifice treatment
Frequently asked questions
What is the most undervalued part of a UK offer?
The employer pension contribution. An employer paying well above the auto-enrolment minimum is providing deferred pay that can exceed a sizeable salary difference, and it is the figure candidates most consistently fail to compare.
Why does the notice period matter so much?
Because it binds you when you want to leave rather than when you join, constraining your next move and any counter-offer. Garden leave provisions also determine whether you spend that period working or sitting out.
When should I get the full written terms?
Before resigning. The written statement of employment particulars is due on or before your first day, but a verbal offer that changes on paper is a known pattern, and a resignation cannot be withdrawn once given.
Which benefits are actually valuable?
Employer pension contributions, death in service cover and genuine salary sacrifice arrangements for pensions, cycles or electric cars. Private medical insurance is usually a taxable benefit, so the list is worth reading for what is taxed and what is insurance.
Can I ask for flexible working in the offer?
Yes, and it is far stronger agreed in writing than relied on culturally. Flexible working is a statutory right to request rather than to have, with the employer required to handle the request reasonably and within a set period, and requests can be made from day one.
What should I check about equity?
The scheme type including whether it is tax-advantaged such as EMI, the vesting schedule and any cliff, the exercise price, what happens if you leave, and the tax treatment on exercise and sale. Without those, the quoted figure is not a number you can rely on.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Job Offer Evaluation Checklist?
Yes. “Why Checklists Work, and How to Use One Properly” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.