South Africa version. South African version: debts and loan in rand, store and clothing accounts alongside cards and personal loans, and how a consolidation loan differs from debt review under the National Credit Act. US version

Debt Consolidation Loan Calculator (South Africa)

Should you combine your credit card, store cards and personal loan into one consolidation loan? Compare repayments and total interest in rands before you sign.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Debt Consolidation Calculator?

A consolidation loan is, in the National Credit Regulator's words, one loan to pay off all debts, with a single monthly repayment to the lender who grants it. It lowers the monthly amount almost every time. Whether it saves money depends on the rate and, even more, on how long you take to repay.

Take a typical mix at example rates: a R 32 000 credit card at 21,5%, a R 9 500 store card at 23%, a R 4 200 clothing account at 24% and a R 28 000 personal loan at 26%. Paying R 3 500 a month as now clears the R 73 700 in 37 months with R 23 493,36 of interest. A consolidation loan at 19% over five years drops the repayment to R 1 911,82, but costs R 41 009,12 in interest: R 17 515,76 more than carrying on.

The same loan paid at your current R 3 500 a month is a different story: it clears in 26 months for R 16 664,81 of interest, R 6 828,55 less than now. If the real problem is that your income no longer covers your living costs and repayments, that is over-indebtedness, and debt counselling is the legal route, not a new loan.

  • Any number of debts with their own rates and payments
  • Origination fee taken from the loan or paid in cash
  • Loan APR with the fee, by the Regulation Z actuarial method
  • Total cost and payoff date for both plans
  • What-if row for keeping your current payment on the loan
  • Warning when a lower rate still costs more, saying whether the term or the fee is why
Read the guide: Balance Transfer vs Debt Consolidation Loan: Running the Numbers

Updated

How to use the Debt Consolidation Calculator

  1. Enter each debt you would pay off with the loan: a name, the balance, the APR and the amount you pay on it each month. Add or remove rows as needed.
  2. Enter the consolidation loan's interest rate and term in months or years.
  3. Enter the origination fee as a percentage of the loan, or 0 if there is none, and choose whether it is taken from the loan or paid in cash.
  4. Compare the new payment, the loan's APR and the total of interest plus fees against your current plan.
  5. Check the row for paying your current total on the loan, then copy the results or share the scenario.

Worked examples

Four accounts into a five-year loan

Input

Credit card R 32 000 at 21,5% (R 1 200 a month), store card R 9 500 at 23% (R 550), clothing account R 4 200 at 24% (R 300), personal loan R 28 000 at 26% (R 1 450); loan at 19% over 60 months, no initiation fee

Output

R 1 911,82 a month, R 1 588,18 less; R 41 009,12 interest against R 23 493,36; costs R 17 515,76 more

The lower rate is outweighed by stretching 37 months of repayments to 60. The calculator flags this case.

Same loan over three years

Input

Same debts; loan at 19% over 36 months

Output

R 2 701,55 a month; R 23 555,75 interest; about the same cost as now (R 62,40 more)

A three-year term roughly breaks even at 19%. A lower rate or keeping up the old R 3 500 a month is what turns it into a saving.

Keeping the old repayment going

Input

Five-year loan at 19%, but paying R 3 500 a month

Output

Cleared in 26 months; R 16 664,81 interest; saves R 6 828,55

If the loan allows early settlement, this is how consolidation pays off. Ask the lender about settlement terms before you sign.

Background and insight

An origination fee is a prepaid finance charge under Regulation Z (12 CFR 1026.4). Many personal lenders deduct it from the proceeds, so if your debts total 12,000 and the fee is 5%, you need to borrow 12,000 ÷ 0.95 = 12,631.58 for 12,000 to reach your creditors. The calculator does this gross-up when you choose "Taken from the loan". If you pay the fee in cash instead, you borrow exactly the debt total.

The loan payment is the level amount that repays the loan over its term: P = L × r ÷ (1 − (1 + r)^−n), with r the annual rate ÷ 12 and n the months. The APR is then found the way Regulation Z Appendix J prescribes: the rate at which the present value of those payments equals the amount financed, which is the loan minus the fee. On 12,631.58 at 12.99% for 36 months with a 631.58 fee, the payment is 425.55 and the APR 16.62%, more than three and a half points above the note rate because the fee is spread over three years.

Your current plan is modelled the way most people actually pay: each debt is charged its APR ÷ 12 every month and receives its own payment until it is gone. Money freed when one debt is cleared is not moved to the others; that strategy is what the debt payoff calculator's avalanche and snowball plans show. The CFPB points out that a consolidation loan's lower monthly payment may simply reflect a longer repayment period, which is why the comparison uses total cost, not the payment alone.

Common use cases

  • Checking a loan offer

    Turn a lender's rate, term and origination fee into a total cost you can compare with your current debts.

  • Choosing a term

    Try 36, 48 and 60 months and see how much a lower payment adds to the total.

  • Deciding which debts to include

    Leave out a low-rate car or student loan and see whether consolidating only the cards does better.

  • Comparing with a balance transfer

    Put the loan's total next to the balance transfer calculator's cost for the same debt.

Tips and limitations

  • Compare the total cost on the quote, including all fees, not just the interest rate.
  • Close the store and clothing accounts you settle, or the balances can build up again on top of the loan.
  • Be wary of offers that promise to cut your debt by a set percentage before anyone has looked at your finances; the NCR warns these are misleading.
  • If you cannot meet your repayments and living costs, speak to a registered debt counsellor before taking new credit.

Sources and further reading

  1. Debt counselling: a debt relief measure for over-indebted consumers, National Credit Regulator. What over-indebted means, consolidation compared with debt counselling, and warnings about misleading debt relief marketing.
  2. Debt counselling, National Credit Regulator. How debt review works under the National Credit Act: application, notice to credit providers, the 60-business-day process, fees, the bureau flag and the clearance certificate.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between debt consolidation and debt review?

A consolidation loan is new credit: one loan pays off your accounts and you repay that lender. Debt review (debt counselling) is a process under the National Credit Act for over-indebted consumers, in which a debt counsellor proposes restructured repayments to your existing credit providers, confirmed by the National Consumer Tribunal or a magistrate's court.

Can I get a consolidation loan while under debt review?

No. The NCR says a consumer under debt counselling cannot apply for further credit until the debts are repaid.

Does consolidating lower my total cost?

Only if the loan's rate and term beat your current plan. In the example a five-year loan at 19% costs R 17 515,76 more, while the same loan repaid at R 3 500 a month saves R 6 828,55.

Who counts as over-indebted?

The NCR says a consumer is over-indebted if their income is not enough to cover all their living expenses and debt repayments. Only over-indebted consumers can apply for debt counselling.

Should I use my bond to consolidate debt?

Adding debt to a home loan usually gives a lower rate but spreads it over many more years and secures it on your home. Run a long term here to see the extra interest that can add.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Debt Consolidation Calculator?

Yes. “Balance Transfer vs Debt Consolidation Loan: Running the Numbers” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.