Ultra-Processed Foods in India: NOVA vs ICMR-NIN Guidelines
Is that namkeen, biscuit or instant noodle ultra-processed? NOVA's four groups next to the ICMR-NIN A, B, C categories and HFSS limits, with Indian labels.
By Redbison Dev · · 10 min read

India edition. Written for India: the ICMR-NIN Dietary Guidelines for Indians (2024) classification of foods by processing and HFSS thresholds per 100 g, compared with NOVA, using ingredient lists with INS numbers for namkeen, instant noodles, biscuits and home staples. US edition
A packet of namkeen, a cream biscuit and a pack of instant noodles all look "processed", but they are not the same kind of processed. The NOVA system sorts food into four groups by how it is made, and calls group 4 ultra-processed foods (UPFs). In 2024 the ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition (ICMR-NIN) added India's own yardstick in its Dietary Guidelines for Indians: Guideline 15 says to minimise high fat, sugar, salt (HFSS) foods and UPFs, and classifies foods both by processing (groups A, B and C) and by energy and added fat, sugar and salt per 100 g (levels 1, 2 and 3). The two systems agree on instant noodles and biscuits; namkeen is where an ingredient-list reading of NOVA and ICMR-NIN's HFSS levels pull apart.
This edition puts typical Indian ingredient lists through the NOVA Food Classifier and the ICMR-NIN thresholds. It is general nutrition information, not medical advice; people with diabetes, hypertension or kidney disease should follow their doctor's or dietitian's advice.
NOVA in one table
NOVA, developed by Carlos Monteiro and colleagues in Brazil and described in an FAO report, classifies all foods into four groups:
| NOVA group | What it is | Indian examples |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Unprocessed or minimally processed | Foods altered only by drying, grinding, pasteurising, freezing and similar | Whole dal, atta from the chakki, fresh vegetables, milk, plain curd |
| 2. Processed culinary ingredients | Oils, ghee, sugar, jaggery, salt used to cook | Mustard oil, ghee, jaggery |
| 3. Processed foods | Group 1 foods with salt, sugar or oil added | Salted peanuts, fresh dosa batter with salt |
| 4. Ultra-processed foods | Industrial formulations with ingredients rarely used at home or "cosmetic" additives | Instant noodles, cream biscuits, carbonated drinks |
The checker looks for group 4 markers: substances not used in home cooking (invert sugar, hydrolysed protein, gluten added as an ingredient) and additives whose job is to change taste, colour or texture (flavour enhancers, emulsifiers, thickeners, colours, sweeteners). If a label names additives by their INS number, as the examples here do, the checker reads INS 471 the same as E471. Preservatives, antioxidants and acidity regulators are not markers on their own.
The ICMR-NIN system: processing and HFSS together
ICMR-NIN's Table 15.2 sorts foods by processing:
- Group A: edible portion unaltered or freshly prepared from common ingredients, with no additives. The guidelines list whole grains and legumes, fresh flours from local mills, freshly cooked curries, and preparations from whole grains and pulses "including dosa & idly batter".
- Group B: may be altered (dried, fermented, fried, canned) and loses some fibre, but has no additives. Examples include polished rice, maida, and commercially available savouries, papads, pickles, sweets and chips.
- Group C: completely altered, mass produced with additives, low in fibre and micronutrients. Examples include commercially produced bread, biscuits, breakfast cereals, sauces, ice cream and all cool drinks and energy drinks. ICMR-NIN states that all Group C foods are UPFs, and places instant noodles, breakfast cereals, soup mixes and cake mixes in the UPF category.
Within each group, the level depends on energy and added nutrients per 100 g of cooked or packaged food, using Table 15.1:
| Per 100 g or 100 ml | Solids | Liquids |
|---|---|---|
| Energy | 250 kcal | 70 kcal |
| Salt | 625 mg | 175 mg |
| Added sugar | 3 g | 2.0 g |
| Added fat | 4.2 g | 1.5 g |
Level 1 is within those limits. Level 2 is more than 250 and up to 500 kcal per 100 g because of added sugar or fat, and level 3 is more than 500 kcal. Levels 2 and 3 are HFSS. Nuts and seeds, which are naturally energy dense, are not classified as HFSS. ICMR-NIN also defines a high-salt diet as more than 5 g of salt a day and high sugar as more than 25 g a day on a 2,000 kcal diet.
Worked examples with Indian labels
The ingredient lists below are typical of their category, written the way Indian packs print them. Paste each into the checker; the energy figures are example label values to show how the ICMR-NIN levels work, so read your own pack.
1. Bhujia-style namkeen. Gram flour (45%), edible vegetable oil (palmolein), moth bean flour, potato, salt, spices and condiments, acidity regulator (INS 330).
- NOVA: group 3 in the checker. INS 330 (citric acid) is an acidity regulator, not a marker. The checker, which reads only the ingredient list, finds no group 4 marker and returns group 3. NOVA's own examples (FAO 2019) count packaged savoury snacks as ultra-processed, so a commercial namkeen is a borderline case even under NOVA.
- ICMR-NIN: commercially available savouries are Group B. At an example 560 kcal per 100 g it is B3, HFSS.
This is the most useful contrast in the edition. An ingredient-list reading can call namkeen "only" processed, but ICMR-NIN's HFSS axis flags it as one of the most energy-dense foods in the cupboard. A label with no markers is not automatically a healthy one.
2. Instant noodles with tastemaker. Noodles: refined wheat flour (maida), palm oil, salt, wheat gluten, thickeners (INS 508, INS 412), acidity regulators (INS 501(i), INS 500(i)), humectant (INS 451(i)). Seasoning: mixed spices, salt, sugar, hydrolysed groundnut protein, flavour enhancers (INS 627, INS 631), thickener (INS 1442).
- NOVA: group 4. The checker finds added gluten, a thickener (INS 412, guar gum), hydrolysed protein, flavour enhancers INS 627 and 631, and a modified starch (INS 1442). INS 508, 500, 501 and 451 are not markers.
- ICMR-NIN: instant noodles are named as UPF, Group C. At an example 440 kcal per 100 g as sold, C2, HFSS.
3. Cream biscuit. Refined wheat flour (maida), sugar, edible vegetable oil (palm), invert sugar syrup, cocoa solids, raising agents (INS 503(ii), INS 500(ii)), salt, emulsifiers (INS 322, INS 471), artificial flavouring substances (vanilla).
- NOVA: group 4, from invert sugar syrup, the emulsifiers INS 322 and INS 471, and the flavouring. The raising agents are not markers.
- ICMR-NIN: biscuits are Group C; at an example 480 kcal per 100 g, C2, HFSS.
4. Fresh dosa batter. Rice, urad dal, fenugreek seeds, salt.
- NOVA: group 3: foods with salt added, no markers.
- ICMR-NIN: listed by name in Group A; level 1 as long as it stays under the per-100 g limits.
5. Chakki atta. Whole wheat flour. NOVA group 1; ICMR-NIN Group A as a fresh flour of whole cereal from a local mill.
Where the two systems disagree
- Namkeen and fried snacks. The checker, which reads only the ingredient list, finds no group 4 marker and returns group 3. NOVA's own examples (FAO 2019) count packaged savoury snacks as ultra-processed, so a commercial namkeen is a borderline case even under NOVA. ICMR-NIN puts commercial savouries in Group B and, at typical energy densities, in the HFSS levels. For an Indian diet, where fried snacks are a large source of oil and salt, the HFSS axis is the more useful warning.
- Commercial bread, paneer and peanut butter. ICMR-NIN lists commercially produced bread, peanut butter and tofu in Group C, and paneer with additives too, whatever the label. NOVA decides by the ingredient list: a bread with only flour, water, yeast and salt is group 3, one with emulsifiers is group 4.
- Culinary ingredients. NOVA treats oil, ghee, sugar and salt as group 2 ingredients for cooking. ICMR-NIN lists cooking oils, refined sugars and salt under Group C, noting that cosmetic additives may be used in processing them, and warns that "even home-made foods may become unhealthy if prepared with high fat, high sugar or salt".
- Fortification. ICMR-NIN says enriching or fortifying a UPF or HFSS food "cannot make them wholesome or healthy". The checker does not treat added vitamins as markers either way.
The traffic lights in the checker are UK limits
The checker also colours fat, saturates, sugars and salt per 100 g using the UK front-of-pack traffic-light limits, for example salt is "high" above 1.5 g per 100 g of food. These are not Indian thresholds. ICMR-NIN's salt threshold for solid foods is 625 mg per 100 g, so a namkeen with 1.2 g of salt per 100 g shows amber in the checker but is well over the ICMR-NIN level. For Indian use, read the traffic lights as a rough guide and compare the label against Table 15.1.
Using this when you shop
- Read the ingredient list first. Any marker means NOVA group 4.
- Then read the nutrition panel per 100 g: over 250 kcal, 625 mg salt, 3 g added sugar or 4.2 g added fat (solids) puts it outside ICMR-NIN level 1.
- Prefer Group A foods for most meals, as the guidelines recommend: whole grains, millets, pulses, vegetables, fruits, nuts and seeds.
- Treat packaged snacks, biscuits, bakery items, sugary drinks and instant foods as occasional, whichever system you use.
Tools for this job
- NOVA Food Classifier: paste an ingredient list, including INS numbers, to see the NOVA group and the markers it found.
- Food Labeling Guide: read nutrition panels and ingredient lists more generally.
For calories and protein targets that fit an Indian diet, see the Indian TDEE and calorie guide.
Frequently asked questions
Is namkeen ultra-processed?
For a namkeen made from gram flour, oil, salt and spices with only an acidity regulator, the checker, which reads only the ingredient list, finds no group 4 marker and returns group 3. NOVA's own examples (FAO 2019) count packaged savoury snacks as ultra-processed, so a commercial namkeen is a borderline case even under NOVA. By ICMR-NIN, commercial savouries are Group B, and at typical energy densities above 500 kcal per 100 g they fall in level 3, HFSS. Either way, it is a food to limit.
Are instant noodles ultra-processed?
Yes on both systems. ICMR-NIN names instant noodles in the UPF category, and a typical ingredient list carries NOVA markers such as flavour enhancers INS 627 and 631, guar gum INS 412 and hydrolysed protein.
What does HFSS mean in the ICMR-NIN guidelines?
High fat, sugar and salt. A food is HFSS when, per 100 g, it has more than 250 kcal because of added sugar or fat (levels 2 and 3), using thresholds of 625 mg salt, 3 g added sugar and 4.2 g added fat for solids. Nuts and seeds are not classed as HFSS.
Which INS numbers signal ultra-processing?
The checker treats colours (INS 100 to 199), most thickeners and emulsifiers in the 400s, flavour enhancers (INS 620 to 640), sweeteners such as INS 950 to 969 and modified starches (INS 1400 to 1452) as markers. Preservatives, antioxidants, acidity regulators and raising agents are not.
Sources and further reading
- Dietary Guidelines for Indians, ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition, 2024. Guideline 15, Tables 15.1 and 15.2: HFSS thresholds and food categories A, B and C.
- ICMR-National Institute of Nutrition, Hyderabad. The institute's dietary guidelines and nutrition resources.
- Ultra-processed foods, diet quality, and health using the NOVA classification system, Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2019. The four NOVA groups, with "sweet or savoury packaged snacks" among the ultra-processed examples.
- Ultra-processed foods: what they are and how to identify them, Public Health Nutrition. Monteiro and colleagues' guide to the markers of ultra-processing.
- SACN statement on processed foods and health, UK Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition. An official reading of the evidence and its limits.
More Nutrition Tools
Every tool in the Nutrition Tools section, free and in your browser.