Weighted Decision Matrix
Compare up to 5 options across 10 weighted criteria, score each from -10 to +10 and get a ranked winner you can download as text or an image.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Decision Maker?
The Decision Maker is a weighted decision matrix. You write the decision as a question, list two to five options, and add up to ten aspects (criteria) such as salary, commute or career growth. Each aspect gets a weight from 1 to 10 for how much it matters, and each option gets a score from -10 to +10 on that aspect, with an optional note explaining why.
When you click Analyze & Decide, every score is multiplied by its aspect weight and the products are added up per option. The option with the highest total is shown as the Recommended Choice, followed by a matrix summary, a per-option breakdown and the gap to the runner-up. You can download the result as a plain-text report or as a PNG image of the results card.
The matrix is saved in your browser's localStorage as you edit, so a reload keeps your work. Nothing is sent to a server for the calculation.
- Up to 5 options and 10 weighted aspects
- Signed scores from -10 to +10 with per-cell notes
- Ranked results, matrix summary and runner-up gap
- Download as a text report or a PNG image
- Saved in localStorage and shareable by URL
Updated
How to use the Decision Maker
- Type the decision into the Decision Title field, for example "Which job offer should I accept?". Click Load Sample to see a filled-in matrix first.
- Click Add Option for each choice (at least two, at most five) and name them in the column headers.
- Click Add Aspect for each criterion (up to ten), name it, then click its weight circle and set 1 to 10 with the slider.
- Click each score circle and drag the slider from -10 to +10. Add a short note under the score to record your reasoning.
- Click Analyze & Decide. After changing anything, click Update the Decision to recalculate, then use Download as Text or Download as Image.
Worked example
The built-in job offer sample
Input
Weights: Salary & Benefits 8, Work-Life Balance 7, Career Growth 9, Company Culture 6 Tech Startup: 6, -2, 9, 8 Fortune 500 Company: 9, 7, 6, 2 Remote Freelance: 7, 9, -1, -3
Output
Fortune 500 Company 187 Tech Startup 163 Remote Freelance 92
Fortune 500 wins with 72 + 49 + 54 + 12 = 187. The startup is 24 points behind, almost entirely because of the -2 on work-life balance (worth -14). Change that score to +4 and the startup totals 205 and takes the lead, which tells you what the decision really hinges on.
Background and insight
Weighted scoring is one of the oldest structured decision methods. Engineers know a close relative as the Pugh matrix, after Stuart Pugh's concept selection method, and decision analysts call the general form a weighted sum model. The idea is simple: separate "how much does this criterion matter?" from "how well does this option do on it?", because people are bad at answering both at once in their heads.
Signed scores are the useful twist here. A plain pros and cons list counts items, so one serious drawback and one trivial perk cancel out. Scoring from -10 to +10 lets a real negative pull an option down, and the weight decides how hard. A -2 on work-life balance with weight 7 costs 14 points; a +9 on career growth with weight 9 adds 81.
The method has known failure modes. If two aspects measure the same thing (say "salary" and "total compensation"), that factor gets counted twice. If you set weights after scoring, you can steer the result toward the option you already preferred. And a total of 187 against 163 is not a precise measurement; small gaps mean the options are close and the notes matter more than the numbers.
Common use cases
Job offers
Weigh salary, growth, commute and team against each other instead of anchoring on the biggest number.
Technology choices
Compare two or three libraries or vendors on maturity, cost, licence and team familiarity, and keep the notes as a record of why.
Big purchases
Score cars, laptops or apartments on the criteria you actually care about, with weights agreed before you look at prices.
Team decisions
Share the matrix link so everyone sees the same weights and scores, and argue about specific cells rather than the overall feeling.
Tips and limitations
- Set the weights before you score anything. Weighting after the fact is the easiest way to make the matrix confirm what you already wanted.
- Keep aspects independent. "Salary" and "total compensation" in the same matrix double-count money.
- Use the full range. If every score is between 5 and 8, the weights decide everything and the matrix stops discriminating.
- Results do not refresh by themselves. After editing a score or weight, click Update the Decision before downloading.
- Equal totals are shown with the first option as the recommendation. Treat a tie, or a gap of a few points, as "too close to call" and decide on the notes.
- The URL updates as you edit, so the address bar link contains your whole matrix. Share it on purpose, and be aware it carries everything you typed.
Sources and further reading
- Decision Analysis (NASA Systems Engineering Handbook, section 6.8), NASA. How engineering teams weight criteria and score alternatives in trade studies
- Decision-matrix method, Wikipedia. Stuart Pugh's concept selection matrix and its weighted variants
Frequently asked questions
How is the decision score calculated?
Each option's total is the sum of score times weight across all aspects. A score of 6 on an aspect weighted 8 contributes 48 points; a score of -2 on an aspect weighted 7 subtracts 14. The option with the highest total is shown as the recommended choice.
Why can scores be negative in a decision matrix?
Negative scores let a real drawback count against an option instead of just earning fewer points. A long commute or a missing benefit can then outweigh a minor perk, which a simple count of pros and cons cannot express. Zero means the aspect makes no difference for that option.
How many options and criteria can I compare?
Up to five options and ten aspects. The limit is deliberate: beyond that, people struggle to score consistently and the matrix turns into busywork. If you have more candidates, triage them first with the Ideas Organizer and bring the best few here.
What should I do if two options tie or are very close?
Treat the result as a tie. The tool lists the first of equal totals as the recommendation, but a difference of a few points is well inside the noise of your own scoring. Read the notes, find the aspect where they differ most, and decide on that.
Is my decision matrix saved or shared anywhere?
It is saved in your browser's localStorage, so a reload restores it on this device. The calculation runs in your browser and nothing is posted to a server, so the matrix is not visible to anyone else unless you export or share it yourself.
What is the difference between a decision matrix and a Pugh matrix?
A Pugh matrix scores each option as better, same or worse than a baseline option on each criterion. A weighted decision matrix like this one scores every option on an absolute scale and multiplies by weights. The weighted version is easier to read when there is no obvious baseline.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Decision Maker?
Yes. “Weighted Decision Matrix and Impact vs Effort Scoring, Worked Through” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.