5x5 Risk Matrix for UK Workplace Risk Assessments

How a 5x5 risk matrix fits a UK risk assessment: what HSE and the 1999 Management Regulations require, scoring before and after controls, and reasonably practicable.

By · · 6 min read

Illustration for the Risk Assessment Matrix guide

United Kingdom edition. Written for UK workplaces: the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999, HSE's five-step approach and template, "reasonably practicable" and a warehouse register scored before and after controls. US edition

A 5x5 risk matrix is the most common way UK employers rate hazards on a risk assessment: likelihood from 1 to 5 times severity from 1 to 5 gives a score from 1 to 25, and the score sets the priority. No law in Great Britain requires a matrix, though. What the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 require is a "suitable and sufficient" assessment of the risks, and HSE's own template has no scoring column at all. Northern Ireland has the same duty, in the same words, under the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations (Northern Ireland) 2000. The matrix earns its place when it helps you rank what to fix first and show that the controls you chose bring the risk down, so use it for that and not as a substitute for the controls themselves.

This edition shows how the matrix fits the UK legal duty and scores a warehouse register in the Risk Assessment Matrix. For the general theory of risk matrices, their maths and their pitfalls, see the US guide to risk matrices.

What the law actually asks for

Regulation 3 of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 says every employer shall make a suitable and sufficient assessment of the risks to the health and safety of its employees at work and of people not in its employment affected by its undertaking. Self-employed people covered by the rules must do the same for themselves and others. The assessment must be reviewed when there is reason to think it is no longer valid or there has been a significant change, and an employer with five or more employees must record the significant findings and any group of employees identified as especially at risk.

HSE's guidance turns that into steps:

  1. Identify what could cause injury or illness (hazards), including health hazards such as manual handling, chemicals and work-related stress.
  2. Decide who might be harmed and how, thinking about young workers, new or expectant mothers, migrant workers and people with disabilities.
  3. Decide how likely it is that someone could be harmed and how seriously: this is assessing the level of risk.
  4. Control the risks: get rid of the hazard if you can; if not, replace the materials or process, organise work to reduce exposure, put practical measures in place, and provide personal protective equipment.
  5. Record significant findings if you employ five or more, and review the controls.

Step 3 is exactly what a matrix encodes: likelihood on one axis and severity on the other. HSE's template records the hazards, who might be harmed, what you are already doing, what further action is needed, who does it and by when. Adding a score before and after controls is a common way to show that the further action matters.

Reasonably practicable, not zero risk

HSE says you are not expected to eliminate all risks, but you must do everything reasonably practicable to protect people. That means balancing the level of risk against the money, time or trouble of the measures needed to control it. The matrix helps with the first half of that balance; it cannot do the second. A score of 5 for a fatal hazard you have controlled as far as practicable is acceptable; a score of 5 for a hazard with a cheap, obvious fix you have not applied is not.

Define the scales for a UK workplace

Agree the words before anyone scores, so that a 4 means the same to the warehouse manager and the safety adviser:

ScoreLikelihoodSeverity
1Not expected in the life of the siteMinor injury, first aid only
2Could happen, has happened elsewhere in the industryInjury needing medical treatment
3Has happened here, or near misses recordedOver-seven-day injury, time off work
4Likely within a yearMajor injury such as a fracture or amputation
5Expected to happen oftenFatality or multiple serious injuries

The Risk Assessment Matrix colours scores of 1 to 4 green (low), 5 to 9 yellow (medium), 10 to 16 orange (high) and 20 to 25 red (critical).

Worked example: a distribution warehouse

A warehouse with 40 staff, two counterbalance lift trucks and a loading bay builds its register in the matrix, scoring each hazard as it stands today and again with the further action from the HSE template:

HazardBefore: L × SScoreFurther actionAfter: L × SScore
Lift truck strikes a pedestrian in the loading bay3 × 515 HighBarriered walkway, separate pedestrian door, banksman at peak times1 × 55 Medium
Manual handling of 25 kg sacks4 × 312 HighVacuum lifter, sacks ordered in smaller units2 × 36 Medium
Racking collapse after an upright is struck2 × 510 HighUpright protectors, weekly checks, damage reporting1 × 55 Medium
Work-related stress in the peak season3 × 39 MediumAgency cover planned, shift limits, stress risk assessment2 × 36 Medium
Slip on a wet floor by the dock door3 × 26 MediumEntrance matting, cleaning schedule, door canopy2 × 24 Low

Three points stand out.

  • Controls move likelihood, not severity. Being struck by a lift truck is still potentially fatal after the walkway goes in, so severity stays 5 and the best possible score is 5. That is why fatal hazards never turn green, and why the reasonably practicable test, not the colour, decides whether you have done enough.
  • The order changes. Before controls the lift truck risk leads at 15; after them the remaining risks sit at 4 to 6, and the stress and manual handling rows are now as high as any. The register shows where the next pound of effort goes.
  • Health risks belong on the same grid. HSE lists manual handling and work-related stress among the hazards to consider. Manual handling has its own duty: avoid hazardous manual handling so far as reasonably practicable, assess what cannot be avoided and reduce the risk to as low as reasonably practicable. HSE notes the law sets no specific weight limits, so the 25 kg sack is judged on the task, not a number.

Common mistakes in UK assessments

  • Copying an example. HSE warns that copying an example and adding your company name would not satisfy the law; the hazards and controls must be your own.
  • Paperwork over practice. HSE says not to rely on paperwork as the main priority; the controls must work in practice.
  • Scoring without consulting. HSE says to involve employees, who usually have good ideas about hazards and controls.
  • Never reviewing. Review when the work changes, after accidents or near misses, or when workers spot problems, and update the record.

Tools for this job

  • Risk Assessment Matrix: score each hazard on 1 to 5 likelihood and severity, see it on the grid and export the register.
  • FMEA Analysis: rate failure modes line by line for a machine or process where a 5x5 is too coarse.

Frequently asked questions

Is a risk matrix a legal requirement in the UK?

No. In Great Britain the 1999 Management Regulations (in Northern Ireland the 2000 Regulations) require a suitable and sufficient risk assessment, and employers with five or more employees must record the significant findings. HSE's template records hazards, controls and actions without a score. A matrix is a common, optional way to rank risks.

How do I score likelihood and severity on a 5x5 matrix?

Write one line for each level of both scales that fits your workplace, such as "has happened here" for likelihood 3 or "fracture or amputation" for severity 4, then multiply. In the warehouse example a lift truck hazard scores 3 × 5 = 15 before controls and 1 × 5 = 5 after.

Why does a controlled hazard still score medium?

Because most controls reduce how likely harm is, not how bad it would be. A hazard that could kill keeps a severity of 5, so its lowest possible score is 5. Whether that is acceptable depends on whether you have done everything reasonably practicable.

How often should a risk assessment be reviewed?

The regulations require a review when there is reason to suspect the assessment is no longer valid or there has been a significant change. HSE adds reviews after accidents or near misses and when workers spot problems.

Sources and further reading

Open the Risk Assessment Matrix

More Business Analysis

Every tool in the Business Analysis section, free and in your browser.