United Kingdom version. Pounds, a deposit and Stamp Duty Land Tax in the purchase costs, no tax relief on your own mortgage, council tax left out because tenants pay it too, and UK selling costs. US version
Rent or Buy Calculator (UK)
Should you rent or buy in the UK? Compare net worth in pounds with Stamp Duty, first-time buyer relief, deposit, estate agent fees and the return on an ISA.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
Buying a £350,000 home in England with a 10% deposit and a 4.5% mortgage over 25 years costs £1,750.87 a month in repayments. Against £1,500 a month in rent, buying looks only slightly dearer, but the real comparison is what each household owns after a few years. Here the first-time buyer moves ahead of the renter in year 2 and is about £105,700 better off after 10 years, assuming 3% house price growth and 5% a year on the renter's savings.
Stamp Duty Land Tax is what changes the short-term answer most. Since 1 April 2025 the standard bands are 0% up to £125,000, 2% to £250,000 and 5% to £925,000, and first-time buyers pay nothing up to £300,000 and 5% from £300,001 to £500,000. On £350,000 that is £2,500 for a first-time buyer and £7,500 for someone who has owned before. Put the tax plus legal, survey and mortgage fees into Purchase Costs; the tool treats them as money that is gone on day one.
Some US inputs do not apply here, so this version sets them to zero. Homeowners get no income tax relief on mortgage interest, so the tax rate is 0. Council tax is paid by whoever lives in the home, renter or owner, so it cancels out and is left at 0. If you are buying a leasehold flat, enter the service charge and ground rent in the yearly charges box, because a renter does not pay them directly.
- Net worth comparison with opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs
- Selling costs, maintenance, property tax, insurance and HOA
- Mortgage interest and property tax deduction at your marginal rate
- Break-even year, cumulative cost and net worth charts
- Shareable link with every input
Updated
How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator
- Enter the asking price and your deposit, then the mortgage rate and term from a lender's illustration (the tool repays it monthly, as UK repayment mortgages do).
- In Purchase Costs, add your Stamp Duty from the GOV.UK bands plus conveyancing, survey and any arrangement fee.
- Set selling costs to the estate agent fee you expect plus conveyancing on the sale, as a percentage of the future price.
- Enter buildings insurance and a maintenance budget for the owner, and contents insurance for the renter. Leave council tax at 0 unless the band would differ between the two homes.
- Choose a return the renter could realistically earn on the deposit, for example inside a Stocks and Shares ISA, and read the break-even year.
Worked examples
First-time buyer, £350,000 house
Input
£35,000 deposit, 4.5% over 25 years, £5,000 purchase costs (£2,500 Stamp Duty with first-time buyer relief, £2,500 fees), 2% selling costs, rent £1,500 a month rising 3%, 3% house prices, 5% on savings, 10 years
Output
Mortgage £1,750.87 a month; renting ahead by £3,713 after year 1; buying ahead from year 2 and by £105,733 after 10 years
Low purchase costs are why the first-time buyer pulls ahead so quickly. The renter starts with £40,000 invested, but the buyer's equity from repayments and price growth outruns it within two years at these assumptions.
The same house for a home mover
Input
As above, but £10,000 purchase costs (£7,500 Stamp Duty at the standard rates, £2,500 fees)
Output
Renting ahead by £8,963 after year 1 and still by £282 after year 2; buying ahead from year 3 and by £97,588 after 10 years
An extra £5,000 of tax pushes the break-even back a year. If you might move within about three years, the result hinges on Stamp Duty and agent fees more than on the mortgage rate.
Short stay: 3 years
Input
First-time buyer case with Analysis Period 3 years
Output
Buying ahead by £14,870; for a home mover, by £9,082
Selling costs are taken off the home's value at the end of each year, so they are already in these figures. A drop in prices would erase that lead, so test 0% growth as well.
Background and insight
The fair comparison is net worth, not monthly payments. The approach follows the structure popularised by the New York Times rent-versus-buy calculator: the renter starts with the down payment and closing costs invested, and every year whichever household spends less invests the difference at the investment return. The buyer ends with the home's value after selling costs, minus the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. Leaving out that opportunity cost makes buying look better than it is.
With the defaults (400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 2,500 rent), the monthly principal and interest is 2,022.62. In year one the buyer is 22,128 behind, mostly because 6% selling costs and 8,000 of closing costs vanish on day one. The buyer moves ahead in year 3 and leads by about 113,700 after 10 years at 3% appreciation and 7% investment return. Set selling costs to 0 and buying wins from year 1, which shows how much transaction costs matter if you might move soon.
The tax line assumes you itemise and can deduct all mortgage interest and property tax. In the US many households take the standard deduction instead, and state and local tax deductions are capped, so for them the real benefit is smaller or zero. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 to see the result without it.
Common use cases
Deciding whether to buy now
Find the break-even year and compare it with how long you expect to stay.
Testing a rate change
Change the Interest Rate to see how much a point on the mortgage moves the payment and the outcome.
Comparing a specific listing and rental
Enter real tax, HOA and rent figures for two homes you are choosing between.
Checking an agent's claim
Test "rent is dead money" by adding the opportunity cost of the down payment.
Tips and limitations
- Mortgage rates here are usually fixed for two or five years and then revert, so run the calculator again at the rate you expect to remortgage at.
- A 5% deposit is possible, but the rate is usually higher than at 10% or 25%; compare the payment at each deposit level.
- Leasehold flats carry service charges and ground rent that can rise; ask for the last few years of charges before you enter a figure.
- Money the renter saves inside an ISA grows free of UK tax, which matches the tool's untaxed investment return.
- Gains on the home you live in are normally free of Capital Gains Tax through Private Residence Relief, which is why the tool does not tax the sale.
Sources and further reading
- Stamp Duty Land Tax: residential property rates, GOV.UK. Standard bands and first-time buyer relief up to £500,000.
- Tax when you sell your home (Private Residence Relief), GOV.UK
- Council Tax, GOV.UK. Who pays council tax, including tenants.
Frequently asked questions
How much Stamp Duty will I pay as a first-time buyer?
In England and Northern Ireland, first-time buyers pay no SDLT up to £300,000 and 5% on the part from £300,001 to £500,000. Above £500,000 the relief is lost and the standard bands apply. On a £350,000 home that is £2,500, against £7,500 at the standard rates. Scotland (LBTT) and Wales (LTT) have their own taxes and bands.
Should I include council tax?
Usually not. The occupier pays council tax, so a renter in the same home pays the same bill as an owner. The comparison only changes if the home you would buy is in a different band from the one you would rent, in which case enter the difference.
Can I claim tax relief on my mortgage interest?
Not on a home you live in. Mortgage interest relief for owner-occupiers no longer exists in the UK, which is why this version sets the tax rate to 0. Landlords letting a property have separate, restricted rules that do not apply to your own home.
What selling costs should I use?
Estate agent fees are agreed with the agent and are often quoted as a percentage plus VAT, and you will also pay a conveyancer on the sale. This version uses 2% of the sale price as an assumption; replace it with the quotes you get.
Do I pay Capital Gains Tax when I sell my home?
Normally not, if it has been your only or main home the whole time you owned it and the garden is under 5,000 square metres. Private Residence Relief can be reduced if you let it out or used part of it only for business.
Is renting dead money in the UK?
No more than mortgage interest, insurance and repairs are. In the first-time buyer example, year 1 costs the owner £24,910 against £18,100 for the renter, and the owner only gets ahead because repayments and price growth build equity. If prices stall, the renter who invests the deposit can stay ahead.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
Yes. “Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.