Investment Thesis Analyzer

Work through a weighted checklist drawn from Buffett, Munger, Lynch and Pabrai, add notes per question, and get a category-by-category score.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Investment Thesis Analyzer?

The Investment Thesis Analyzer is a structured checklist for the questions you should be able to answer before buying a stock or an ETF. Pick Stock or ETF, type the ticker and name, then tick each statement that is true for the investment. Every question carries a weight from 2 to 5 points, and the tool adds up the ticked weights into an overall percentage and a score for each category, such as Competitive Advantage, Valuation or Cost Efficiency.

The stock checklist has 15 questions grouped by the investor who popularised the idea: Warren Buffett on understanding the business and its moat, Charlie Munger on quality and psychology, Peter Lynch on growth and the PEG ratio, and Mohnish Pabrai on asymmetric risk. The ETF checklist has 7 questions about the index, expense ratio, liquidity, tracking error and fit in your portfolio.

The score measures how many of your own answers were yes. It does not look up any data, and the labels it prints (from Strong Buy to Avoid) only describe that score. Everything stays in the page; nothing is saved or sent anywhere, so download the report if you want to keep it.

  • 15 weighted stock questions and 7 ETF questions
  • Per-category scores and an overall percentage
  • Notes field under every question
  • Text report and PNG summary downloads
  • No account, nothing stored or uploaded
Read the guide: Stock Valuation Basics: P/E, P/B, DCF and a Written Thesis

Updated

How to use the Investment Thesis Analyzer

  1. Choose Stock or ETF under Investment Type. The question set changes with it.
  2. Enter the Ticker Symbol and Company/Fund Name. The results card appears once a ticker is set and at least one answer has been given.
  3. Open each category tab and tick the questions that are true. Use the notes box under each question to record the evidence.
  4. Read the overall percentage, the label and the Category Breakdown to see where the case is weak.
  5. Use Download Report for a text file with every answer and note, or Download Summary Image for a PNG of the results card.

Worked examples

Weights in action

Input

Stock checklist; tick only the two 5-point Buffett questions (understand the business, durable moat)

Output

10 of 53 points, 18.9%, label "Avoid"

The stock checklist is worth 53 points in total. Two strong answers are not a thesis: valuation, management and balance sheet are still unanswered, and the score says so.

Loading the sample

Input

Click Sample with Stock selected

Output

First 12 of 15 questions ticked, score shown immediately

The sample ticks the first 80% of questions and fills in three example notes so you can see how the report reads before writing your own.

Background and insight

A written thesis is the cheapest protection against the most common investing error: buying for a reason you cannot state and selling for a reason you did not plan for. Buffett's "circle of competence", Munger's habit of inverting a problem and Lynch's two-minute drill in One Up on Wall Street (1989) all push in the same direction: if you cannot explain why the business will earn more in five years, the price you pay is a guess.

Weighting matters because not every question is equal. A missing moat (5 points) is a bigger problem than an expensive sector (2 points). The tool scores unticked questions as "no", so the percentage moves as soon as you start and you can see which categories drag the total down. A practical way to use it is to write the note first and only tick the box if the note would convince a sceptical colleague.

Common use cases

  • Pre-purchase discipline

    Force yourself to answer the moat, management and valuation questions before placing an order.

  • Comparing two candidates

    Score two stocks against the same checklist and compare which categories differ.

  • Picking between similar ETFs

    Run two S&P 500 funds through the ETF checklist to focus on cost, liquidity and tracking error.

  • Investment club write-ups

    Share the downloaded report so members can challenge the notes rather than the conclusion.

  • Post-mortems

    Re-score a past purchase with hindsight to see which questions you answered too optimistically.

Tips and limitations

  • The labels Strong Buy, Buy, Hold, Caution and Avoid are fixed thresholds (80%, 70%, 60%, 40%) on your own answers. They are not a rating on the security and this is an educational tool, not financial advice.
  • Answers and notes are lost when you leave or reload the page. Download the report before closing the tab.
  • Switching between Stock and ETF clears the result, because the two checklists have different questions and weights.
  • Pair the checklist with numbers: check P/E, P/B and dividend yield in the Stock Analysis Calculator before ticking the valuation question.
  • If you tick a box without writing a note, treat that answer as a guess.

Sources and further reading

  1. Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letters, Berkshire Hathaway. Warren Buffett's annual letters on moats, management and the circle of competence
  2. Updated Investor Bulletin: Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs), US Securities and Exchange Commission. How ETFs work, what they cost and how they trade
  3. Expense Ratio, US Securities and Exchange Commission. Definition of the fund cost the ETF checklist asks about

Frequently asked questions

What should an investment thesis include?

An investment thesis should say what the business does, why it can keep earning above-average returns, what you expect to happen and by when, what price you are willing to pay, and what would prove you wrong. The analyzer's categories map to those parts, so a low score in one category shows which piece of the argument is missing.

How is the investment thesis score calculated?

Each question has a weight between 2 and 5 points. Ticked questions add their weight and unticked ones add nothing, then the total is divided by the maximum (53 points for stocks, 24 for ETFs). Category scores use the same rule within each category.

Does a Strong Buy result mean I should buy the stock?

No. The label only reflects how many of your own checklist answers were yes, above 80% in this case. The tool fetches no prices or financials, so it cannot judge whether the stock is cheap; it shows whether your reasoning covers the main questions.

Which famous investors are the checklist questions based on?

The stock questions draw on Warren Buffett (understandable business, moat, management, cash flow), Charlie Munger (quality at a fair price, avoiding biases), Peter Lynch (simple story, growth room, PEG below 1) and Mohnish Pabrai (limited downside, capital-light model, niche leadership), plus three general balance sheet and market checks.

What questions should I ask before buying an ETF?

Ask whether the index is well defined, whether the expense ratio is reasonable for the category, whether volume and bid-ask spreads are healthy, whether holdings are diversified, how closely it tracks the index, whether the provider is established, and whether it fills a gap in your portfolio. Those are the seven ETF questions here.

Can I save my thesis and come back later?

Not inside the tool. Answers and notes live only in the open page and disappear on reload. Use Download Report to keep a text copy with every question, answer and note, which you can store with your other investment records.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Investment Thesis Analyzer?

Yes. “Stock Valuation Basics: P/E, P/B, DCF and a Written Thesis” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.