Rent vs Buy Calculator
Compare renting and buying a home by net worth: mortgage, tax, upkeep, selling costs and the investment return on money a renter would not tie up.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
The Rent vs Buy Calculator compares two people in the same situation over the same number of years. One buys a home with a mortgage; the other rents and invests the money the buyer had to spend. At the end of each year it compares their net worth and reports which side is ahead, the break-even year, cumulative costs on both sides and the home value and equity.
Buying costs include principal and interest, property tax, home insurance, maintenance and HOA fees, minus the tax saved by deducting mortgage interest and property tax at your marginal rate. Owner costs and renter's insurance grow with the inflation rate, and rent grows with the annual rent increase. The buyer's home is valued after selling costs, which default to 6% of the sale price.
All the maths runs in your browser, and Copy Results Link puts every input in a link you can reopen. The result depends heavily on the growth and return rates you choose, so it is a way to test assumptions, not a recommendation and not financial advice.
- Net worth comparison with opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs
- Selling costs, maintenance, property tax, insurance and HOA
- Mortgage interest and property tax deduction at your marginal rate
- Break-even year, cumulative cost and net worth charts
- Shareable link with every input
Updated
How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator
- Under Home Purchase, enter Home Price, Down Payment, Closing Costs, Interest Rate, Loan Term and Selling Costs (% of sale price).
- Under the ownership costs, enter annual Property Tax, Home Insurance, Maintenance & Repairs and HOA Fees.
- Under Renting, enter Monthly Rent, Annual Renter's Insurance and Annual Rent Increase.
- Set Annual Home Appreciation, Investment Return, Inflation Rate, Marginal Tax Rate and the Analysis Period.
- Read the recommendation badge and break-even year, then the Comparison, Projections and Analysis tabs. Copy Results Link saves the scenario.
Worked examples
Default scenario over 10 years
Input
400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 6% selling costs, 2,500 rent rising 3%, 3% appreciation, 7% investment return
Output
Payment 2,022.62 a month; break-even year 3; buyer ahead by about 113,724 after 10 years
After 10 years the buyer's net worth is about 286,800 (home after selling costs, minus the loan, plus invested savings) against about 173,100 for the renter.
Short stay
Input
Same inputs, Analysis Period 1 year
Output
Renting ahead by about 22,128
Closing and selling costs take more than a year of appreciation and principal to recover. If you might move within two years, closing and selling costs often outweigh any equity you build, so check that case before you buy.
Background and insight
The fair comparison is net worth, not monthly payments. The approach follows the structure popularised by the New York Times rent-versus-buy calculator: the renter starts with the down payment and closing costs invested, and every year whichever household spends less invests the difference at the investment return. The buyer ends with the home's value after selling costs, minus the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. Leaving out that opportunity cost makes buying look better than it is.
With the defaults (400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 2,500 rent), the monthly principal and interest is 2,022.62. In year one the buyer is 22,128 behind, mostly because 6% selling costs and 8,000 of closing costs vanish on day one. The buyer moves ahead in year 3 and leads by about 113,700 after 10 years at 3% appreciation and 7% investment return. Set selling costs to 0 and buying wins from year 1, which shows how much transaction costs matter if you might move soon.
The tax line assumes you itemise and can deduct all mortgage interest and property tax. In the US many households take the standard deduction instead, and state and local tax deductions are capped, so for them the real benefit is smaller or zero. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 to see the result without it.
Common use cases
Deciding whether to buy now
Find the break-even year and compare it with how long you expect to stay.
Testing a rate change
Change the Interest Rate to see how much a point on the mortgage moves the payment and the outcome.
Comparing a specific listing and rental
Enter real tax, HOA and rent figures for two homes you are choosing between.
Checking an agent's claim
Test "rent is dead money" by adding the opportunity cost of the down payment.
Tips and limitations
- Year-one rent is the rent you enter; increases start in year two.
- The investment return applies to the renter's down payment and to whichever side saves money each year. If you would not actually invest the difference, renting's advantage is overstated.
- Maintenance of about 1% of the home's value a year is a common rule of thumb; older homes often need more.
- Appreciation and investment return dominate the result. Run a pessimistic case (1% and 5%) next to the default.
- Payments stop once the loan is repaid, so a 15-year loan in a 20-year analysis shows five payment-free years.
Sources and further reading
- Publication 936, Home Mortgage Interest Deduction, Internal Revenue Service. Who can deduct mortgage interest and the limits
- Topic no. 503, Deductible taxes, Internal Revenue Service. The cap on state and local tax deductions, including property tax
- Topic no. 501, Should I itemize?, Internal Revenue Service. Why many households take the standard deduction instead
- Buying a house, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Closing costs, loan options and the steps to buying
Frequently asked questions
How do you calculate whether to rent or buy?
Compare net worth at the end of the period, not monthly payments. Give the renter the down payment and closing costs to invest, invest the yearly cost difference on whichever side is cheaper, and value the home after selling costs and the remaining mortgage. Whichever household ends richer made the better financial choice.
What is the opportunity cost of a down payment?
It is what the money would have earned if you had invested it instead of putting it into a house. In the default scenario, 88,000 of down payment and closing costs invested at 7% grows to about 94,000 in one year, and the renter keeps that growth.
How many years do I need to stay for buying to beat renting?
It depends on transaction costs, appreciation and rent, but many scenarios break even after 3 to 7 years. With this calculator's defaults the buyer moves ahead in year 3; with no rent growth or lower appreciation it takes longer.
Does the rent vs buy calculator include selling costs?
Yes. Selling costs default to 6% of the future sale price and are subtracted from the home's value when the buyer's net worth is calculated. Agent commissions, transfer taxes and fees vary by market, so adjust the percentage to match yours.
Is the mortgage interest tax deduction realistic in this calculator?
It assumes you itemise and deduct all mortgage interest and property tax at your marginal rate, which overstates the benefit for anyone taking the standard deduction or hitting the cap on state and local tax deductions. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 for a conservative comparison.
Is rent really dead money?
No. Rent buys housing, just as mortgage interest, property tax, insurance and maintenance do, and none of those build equity either. Only principal repayment and appreciation build the buyer's wealth, and the renter can build wealth by investing what they did not spend.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Rent vs Buy Calculator?
Yes. “Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.