New Zealand version. NZ dollars, rent converted from the weekly figure, a 20% deposit or a 5% First Home Loan, lawyer, LIM and inspection costs up front, council rates, and no tax deduction for interest on your own home. US version

Rent or Buy Calculator (New Zealand)

Rent or buy in New Zealand? Compare net worth in NZ dollars from weekly rent, a 20% or 5% deposit, council rates, lawyer and LIM costs and the bright-line test.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Rent vs Buy Calculator?

Rents in New Zealand are quoted by the week, so convert first: NZ$650 a week is NZ$2,816.67 a month (650 x 52 / 12). Against that, an NZ$850,000 house with the 20% deposit most lenders ask first home buyers for, and a 5.5% loan over 30 years, costs NZ$3,860.97 a month in repayments before rates, insurance and upkeep. With prices rising 3% a year and the renter investing the deposit at 6%, renting is still about NZ$25,500 ahead after 10 years. At 4% a year price growth, buying pulls ahead from year 4.

The cash a buyer spends on day one is mostly the deposit. settled.govt.nz lists the other costs to budget for as legal fees, a council LIM report and a building inspection, then moving; ongoing costs are maintenance, council rates, insurance and body corporate fees for a unit. Enter those in the up-front and yearly boxes. This version sets the tax rate to 0, because the deduction the tax box models is a US one: Inland Revenue lets landlords deduct rental expenses against rental income, and an owner-occupied home earns none.

Two NZ-specific rules change the timing. A First Home Loan, underwritten by Kāinga Ora, can need only a 5% deposit, which makes buying cheaper up front but leaves a bigger loan. And if you sell a home that has not been your main home within two years, the bright-line test can tax the gain. Renters have their own protection: Tenancy Services says rent can only go up 12 months after the last increase, with 60 days' written notice.

  • Net worth comparison with opportunity cost of the down payment and closing costs
  • Selling costs, maintenance, property tax, insurance and HOA
  • Mortgage interest and property tax deduction at your marginal rate
  • Break-even year, cumulative cost and net worth charts
  • Shareable link with every input
Read the guide: Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments

Updated

How to use the Rent vs Buy Calculator

  1. Convert the weekly rent to monthly (weekly x 52 / 12) and enter it, with the yearly rent increase you expect.
  2. Enter the price, your deposit, the interest rate and the loan term. Repayments are worked monthly.
  3. In the up-front costs box, put lawyer or conveyancer fees, the LIM report, a building inspection and moving costs.
  4. Enter council rates, house insurance, maintenance and body corporate levies for a unit. Leave the tax rate at 0.
  5. Set selling costs to the agent's commission and marketing you expect, and compare the break-even year with how long you plan to stay.

Worked examples

NZ$850,000 house with a 20% deposit

Input

NZ$850,000, NZ$170,000 deposit, 5.5% over 30 years, NZ$4,000 up front (lawyer, LIM, inspection), rates NZ$3,800, insurance NZ$2,500, maintenance NZ$4,000, 3% selling costs; rent NZ$650 a week (NZ$2,816.67 a month) rising 3%; prices 3%; investments 6%; 10 years

Output

Repayments NZ$3,860.97 a month; after 10 years renting is ahead by NZ$25,496.29; no break-even inside 10 years

Even at 15 years the renter is still about NZ$21,655 ahead on these assumptions, because the repayments and running costs exceed the rent by enough that the renter keeps investing a surplus.

Same house if prices rise 4% a year

Input

As above with home price growth of 4%

Output

Buying moves ahead in year 4 and leads by NZ$86,906.07 after 10 years

One point of extra price growth swings the result by more than NZ$112,000. The answer is very sensitive to the growth you assume, so test a range rather than one figure.

NZ$650,000 townhouse with a 5% First Home Loan

Input

NZ$650,000, NZ$32,500 deposit, 5.5% over 30 years, NZ$3,500 up front, rates NZ$3,000, insurance NZ$2,000, maintenance NZ$3,000; rent NZ$550 a week (NZ$2,383.33 a month); prices 3%; investments 6%

Output

Repayments NZ$3,506.10 a month; buying moves ahead in year 6 and leads by NZ$25,101.47 after 10 years

A small deposit leaves the renter little to invest, so the buyer catches up sooner. A low-deposit loan may carry a different rate or fees, so enter the terms you are actually offered.

Selling after four years

Input

The first example over 4 years

Output

Renting ahead by NZ$28,338.63

Selling costs and the early years of mostly-interest repayments make a short stay expensive. If the home had not been your main home and you sold inside two years, the bright-line test could also tax the gain.

Background and insight

The fair comparison is net worth, not monthly payments. The approach follows the structure popularised by the New York Times rent-versus-buy calculator: the renter starts with the down payment and closing costs invested, and every year whichever household spends less invests the difference at the investment return. The buyer ends with the home's value after selling costs, minus the remaining loan, plus anything they invested. Leaving out that opportunity cost makes buying look better than it is.

With the defaults (400,000 home, 80,000 down, 8,000 closing, 6.5% for 30 years, 2,500 rent), the monthly principal and interest is 2,022.62. In year one the buyer is 22,128 behind, mostly because 6% selling costs and 8,000 of closing costs vanish on day one. The buyer moves ahead in year 3 and leads by about 113,700 after 10 years at 3% appreciation and 7% investment return. Set selling costs to 0 and buying wins from year 1, which shows how much transaction costs matter if you might move soon.

The tax line assumes you itemise and can deduct all mortgage interest and property tax. In the US many households take the standard deduction instead, and state and local tax deductions are capped, so for them the real benefit is smaller or zero. Set Marginal Tax Rate to 0 to see the result without it.

Common use cases

  • Deciding whether to buy now

    Find the break-even year and compare it with how long you expect to stay.

  • Testing a rate change

    Change the Interest Rate to see how much a point on the mortgage moves the payment and the outcome.

  • Comparing a specific listing and rental

    Enter real tax, HOA and rent figures for two homes you are choosing between.

  • Checking an agent's claim

    Test "rent is dead money" by adding the opportunity cost of the down payment.

Tips and limitations

  • NZ$600 a week is NZ$2,600 a month, not NZ$2,400: always use weekly x 52 / 12.
  • Get conditional pre-approval before you look; settled.govt.nz notes you need it to buy at auction.
  • A KiwiSaver first-home withdrawal can add to your deposit; check timing with your provider well before settlement.
  • Budget for the LIM and building inspection on properties you do not end up buying too: you pay for them either way.

Sources and further reading

  1. Thinking about your finances when buying, settled.govt.nz. 20% deposit; First Home Loan with 5%; KiwiSaver first-home withdrawal; additional costs; GST; bright-line.
  2. The bright-line test, Inland Revenue. 2-year bright-line period for property sold on or after 1 July 2024; main home exclusion.
  3. Increasing rent, Tenancy Services (MBIE). Rent increases at most every 12 months, with 60 days' written notice.
  4. Residential rental property deductions, Inland Revenue. Deductions are claimed against rental income; the rules do not apply to your main home.

Frequently asked questions

How much deposit do I need to buy a house in NZ?

settled.govt.nz says most lenders ask first home buyers for at least 20% of the price, so an NZ$900,000 home needs about NZ$180,000. A First Home Loan underwritten by Kāinga Ora may need only 5%, subject to the lender, where you live and what you can afford.

What costs are there when buying a house in New Zealand?

Besides the deposit: legal fees, a council LIM report, a building inspection and moving costs, then ongoing rates, insurance, maintenance and body corporate fees for a unit. Residential purchases do not usually include GST, though there are exceptions when the buyer or seller is GST registered.

Is it cheaper to rent or buy in NZ?

It depends on the price growth you expect and how long you stay. In the examples, renting stays ahead of an NZ$850,000 house for 10 years at 3% price growth, while 4% growth puts buying ahead from year 4. A smaller deposit with a First Home Loan tips the comparison towards buying sooner.

Does the bright-line test apply to my own home?

Generally not when it has been your main home and your use meets Inland Revenue's criteria. For other residential property sold on or after 1 July 2024, a gain is taxable if the property is sold within 2 years of the bright-line start date, usually settlement.

How often can my landlord put the rent up?

Only once every 12 months: an increase can take effect no sooner than 12 months after the tenancy started and 12 months after the last increase, and the landlord must give at least 60 days' written notice. Use that to choose a realistic yearly rent increase here.

Can I claim mortgage interest on my home?

Not on a home you live in. Inland Revenue's deduction rules cover expenses against rental income, so they only matter if you rent the property out. That is why the tax rate in this version is 0.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Rent vs Buy Calculator?

Yes. “Rent vs Buy: Comparing Net Worth, Not Monthly Payments” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.