Singapore version. Singapore dollars, your own return assumptions instead of US presets, and how to enter the 30% US dividend withholding that MoneySense says applies to US-domiciled ETFs held by Singapore investors. US version

ETF Investment Calculator (Singapore)

Project monthly ETF investing in S$ and see what fund domicile does: 30% US withholding on dividends from US-domiciled ETFs against fees, with inflation.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the ETF Investment Simulator?

Many ETFs track the same index, and MoneySense, the Singapore Government's financial education site, points out that they differ in cost, currency, domicile and how dividends are treated. An ETF domiciled in the US and held by a Singapore investor has 30% US withholding tax taken from its dividends, and for a dividend-paying ETF MoneySense says this can affect your net return, sometimes more than the difference in fees.

The calculator has no separate withholding box, so build it into the inputs. Take the expected total return and the dividend yield, work out 30% of the yield, and subtract it from both. A fund returning 6% a year with a 1.5% yield loses 0.45 points, so enter 5.55% and 1.05%. With S$10,000 now and S$1,000 a month for 20 years at a 0.03% fee, that gives S$460,174 against S$485,031 with no withholding: about S$24,900 less.

There is a second US cost the projection does not show. The IRS treats stock of US corporations as US-situated for estate tax, and the executor of a non-resident whose US-situated assets exceed US$60,000 must file a US estate tax return. Projections assume a steady return with no bad years; treat them as a comparison of fees, tax drag and time, not a forecast.

  • Ten preset ETFs or custom return and yield
  • Weekly, bi-weekly, semi-monthly or monthly contributions
  • Scheduled contribution increases
  • Dividend reinvestment toggle, expense ratio and inflation
  • Year-by-year table, growth chart and shareable link
Read the guide: ETF Fees, Dividends and Monthly Investing Over 30 Years

Updated

How to use the ETF Investment Simulator

  1. Turn on custom returns and enter the total return you want to test and the fund's dividend yield from its factsheet.
  2. For a US-domiciled ETF, subtract 30% of the yield from both figures (6% and 1.5% become 5.55% and 1.05%).
  3. Enter the fund's total expense ratio (TER), your starting sum and monthly amount in S$, and the number of years.
  4. Read the final value, the value at today's prices and the fees paid, then rerun with another fund to compare.

Worked examples

US-domiciled S&P 500 ETF, 30% withholding

Input

S$10,000 start, S$1,000 a month for 20 years; 6% return and 1.5% yield reduced to 5.55% and 1.05%; TER 0.03%; reinvested; 2% inflation

Output

About S$460,174 (S$309,684 at today's prices); S$250,000 paid in; fees about S$1,142

The withholding takes 0.45 points of return every year. Over 20 years it costs more than 20 times this fund's S$1,142 fee bill (see the next example).

The same index with no dividend withholding

Input

As above at 6% and 1.5%, TER 0.03%

Output

About S$485,031 (S$326,412 at today's prices)

About S$24,857 more. A fund with a 0.5% TER and no withholding ends at about S$459,104, close to the US-domiciled result: the tax drag here is worth roughly 0.47 points of TER.

MoneySense's fee example: S$50,000 for 20 years

Input

S$50,000 lump sum, no monthly amount, 6% return, 1.5% yield reinvested; TER 0.1% then 0.5%

Output

S$157,358 at 0.1% against S$145,888 at 0.5%; fees about S$1,820 against S$8,717

MoneySense says the gap between a 0.1% and a 0.5% TER on S$50,000 over 20 years compounds to thousands of dollars; on these assumptions it is about S$11,470.

Background and insight

The simulation runs a year at a time with the mid-year convention: contributions arrive evenly through the year, so on average half of the year's money earns a full year's return. The total return is split into price growth (return minus yield) and dividends (yield × average balance). With Reinvest Dividends on, dividends are added to the balance; with it off, they are paid out and the final value is lower. With the SPY preset, 10,000 plus 500 a month rising by 50 a year ends at about 2.13 million after 30 years with reinvestment and about 1.70 million without.

Fees work the same way returns do, in reverse: an expense ratio is charged on the average balance every year. Over 30 years at 7%, 10,000 plus 500 a month ends at about 662,700 with no fee, 658,800 at 0.03% and 546,000 at 1%. That 1% looks small on a factsheet and costs about 117,000 here. Fund returns you look up are normally reported after fees already, so only add an expense ratio when your return assumption is a gross market return.

Inflation turns long projections into smaller real numbers. The default SPY scenario with 5,000 to start reaches about 2.04 million nominal after 30 years, which is about 973,000 at today's prices at 2.5% inflation.

Common use cases

  • Planning a monthly ETF habit

    See what 300, 500 or 1,000 a month into a broad index fund could reach by retirement.

  • Comparing fund costs

    Run the same plan at 0.03% and 0.75% to see what a pricier fund costs over decades.

  • Payroll-based investing

    Match the contribution frequency to a bi-weekly or semi-monthly pay schedule.

  • Dividend reinvestment decisions

    Toggle Reinvest Dividends to see how much of the result comes from compounding the payouts.

Tips and limitations

  • Check whether the ETF is authorised for sale to retail investors in Singapore and whether it is a Specified Investment Product; if so, your broker may ask you to complete a Customer Account Review first.
  • An accumulating fund reinvests dividends for you; a distributing one pays them out. MoneySense notes accumulating funds can be more efficient for long-term investors in a tax-free environment.
  • Bid-ask spreads and brokerage are costs the TER does not include. On a monthly plan, add an estimate to the expense ratio for an all-in figure.
  • A USD fund also carries USD/SGD currency risk, which this projection does not model.

Sources and further reading

  1. How do I choose between ETFs that track the same index?, MoneySense (Singapore Government). 30% US withholding on US-domiciled ETFs held by Singapore investors; TER range; S$50,000 over 20 years; checklist.
  2. Dividends, Inland Revenue Authority of Singapore. Foreign dividends received by resident individuals and Singapore unit trust dividends not taxable.
  3. Some nonresidents with U.S. assets must file estate tax returns, Internal Revenue Service. US corporate stock is US-situated; filing required above US$60,000.

Frequently asked questions

How much withholding tax do Singapore investors pay on US ETFs?

MoneySense says an ETF domiciled in the US and held by a Singapore investor is subject to a 30% US withholding tax on dividends. The IRS applies 30% to US-source dividends unless a treaty lowers it, and Singapore is not on the IRS list of treaty partners.

Should I buy a US-listed or an Ireland-domiciled ETF?

MoneySense's checklist asks whether the fund is domiciled in a jurisdiction with a favourable dividend withholding tax treaty, alongside its TER, tracking difference, liquidity and whether it distributes or accumulates. Run both in this calculator with each fund's yield, TER and the withholding that applies, and compare.

Do I pay Singapore tax on ETF dividends?

IRAS does not tax foreign dividends received in Singapore by resident individuals, except through a partnership, and dividends from Singapore unit trusts are on its non-taxable list. The withholding taken abroad is the tax that matters.

Is there US estate tax on US ETFs for Singaporeans?

The IRS lists stock of US corporations among US-situated assets for estate tax, and the executor of a non-resident non-citizen must file Form 706-NA if those assets exceed US$60,000 at death. Ask an adviser how this applies to your holdings.

How many ETFs do I need?

MoneySense says that for a given exposure you only need one ETF; holding several tracking the same index adds cost and complexity without adding diversification.

Is there an in-depth guide to the ETF Investment Simulator?

Yes. “ETF Fees, Dividends and Monthly Investing Over 30 Years” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.