Job Reference Checklist
Ask before you name anyone, brief them properly, and know what an employer may and may not say. Plus the background checks that are not references.
The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.
About this toolWhat is the Job Reference Checklist?
References fail quietly. A referee is called cold and gives a lukewarm answer, or an employer provides only dates and the candidate never learns why an offer evaporated. Both are avoidable, and the fixes take one message each.
This list covers both sides plus a third thing people conflate with references: background checks, which have their own consent rules and their own errors to correct.
- Covers both asking for and giving a reference
- Flags the policy question that quietly limits most corporate references
- Names the subjects that make a reference a discrimination risk
- Separates background checks, which have their own consent rules and errors
- Editable and exportable as PDF, CSV, Markdown or a Google Form
Updated
How to use the Job Reference Checklist
- Ask permission before naming anyone, choosing someone who actually saw your work.
- Send them the advert, your CV and the role requirements, and tell them when to expect contact.
- Check whether their employer permits personal references, and agree when your current employer may be contacted.
- If you are giving one, check your organisation's policy, stay with job-related facts, and avoid anything about health or protected characteristics.
- Find out which background checks the role requires, and check your own credit and criminal records first.
Worked examples
Applying for a job
Input
Asking section
Output
Referees asked and briefed, timing warned, policies checked
An unprepared referee is a weak referee.
Old manager has left
Input
Awkward situations
Output
Colleague, client or supplier used instead
Most employers accept a professional reference.
Asked to give a reference
Input
Giving section
Output
Policy checked, facts only, protected characteristics avoided
Misleading references create liability both ways.
Background and insight
The asking half comes down to choosing the right person and briefing them. A specific answer from a direct manager who saw your work beats a vague one from a director who barely remembers you, and sending the advert, your CV and what the role needs makes it easy to be specific. Telling them when the call is likely to arrive matters because a referee on holiday is a stalled offer and employers often will not chase twice.
One thing people do not check: many organisations only confirm dates and job title through HR and forbid personal references, which means you need another referee as well rather than discovering the limitation at offer stage.
On awkward situations, the general rule is that an employer who hears something from you can weigh it, while one who discovers it from a reference assumes the worst. For a missing manager, most employers accept a professional reference from a colleague, client or supplier. And in many places you have a right to see a reference held about you by the receiving employer, so an offer that disappears after references is worth asking about.
The giving half carries real legal exposure. A reference can expose an employer to a claim from either the candidate or the new employer if it is misleading, including by omission, which is why a deliberately thin reference about something serious is not the safe option people assume. Health, disability, age, pregnancy, religion and family circumstances have no place in a reference, sickness absence included, because that is discrimination territory. Declining is clean; a damning reference is a dispute.
Background checks are separate. They generally require explicit consent, the scope should be proportionate to the role, and both credit files and criminal record disclosures contain errors that take weeks to correct, which is a good argument for checking your own record before an employer does. The rules on declaring old or spent convictions differ by country and by role, and over-disclosing can harm you unnecessarily.
Common use cases
Job hunting
Choosing and briefing referees so the reference actually helps.
An awkward employment history
Gaps, a bad exit, or a manager who has left.
Writing a reference
What may and may not be said, and when to decline instead.
Facing background checks
Consent, scope, and correcting errors before they cost you an offer.
Tips and limitations
- Never list someone who has not agreed. A surprised referee is worse than an unprepared one.
- Pick the person who saw your work, not the most senior person you know.
- Agree explicitly when your current employer may be contacted; normally only after an offer.
- If you left badly, say so first. Being told beats being discovered.
- Check your own credit file and record disclosures before an employer does; errors take weeks to fix.
Sources and further reading
- Providing a job reference, Acas. What may be said, fairness and declining to give one
- Work references, UK Government. When employers must give one and what it can contain
- Background Checks: What Employers Need to Know, US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Consent, scope and discrimination limits on checks
Frequently asked questions
How should I ask for a job reference?
Ask before naming them, choose someone who actually saw your work rather than the most senior person you know, and send them the advert, your CV and what the role needs. Tell them when the request is likely to arrive so it does not sit unanswered.
Can an employer give a bad reference?
They can give an accurate and fair one, including unfavourable facts, but a misleading reference can expose them to a claim from either the candidate or the new employer. That includes misleading by omission, which is why a deliberately thin reference is not the safe option.
What can an employer not say in a reference?
Anything about health, disability, age, pregnancy, religion or family circumstances, sickness absence included, because those stray into discrimination. Good practice is to answer what was asked and stay with job-related facts: dates, role, responsibilities and performance.
What if my old manager has left the company?
Use a colleague, a client or a supplier who worked with you; most employers accept a professional reference from someone other than a line manager. Check separately whether the former employer will confirm dates and title through HR.
Can I find out what my reference said?
Often yes. In many places you have a right to see a reference held about you by the employer who received it, even where the one who wrote it is not obliged to show you. If an offer disappears after references, it is worth asking.
Is there an in-depth guide to the Job Reference Checklist?
Yes. “Why Checklists Work, and How to Use One Properly” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.
Related Tools You May Like
Free, in-browser tools that pair well with this one.