Salary Negotiation Checklist

Research three sources, set a walk-away and a target, let them name a number first, negotiate the whole package, and never accept on the call.

The interactive tool loads here when JavaScript runs.

About this tool

What is the Salary Negotiation Checklist?

Negotiation is mostly preparation. The conversation itself is short, and nearly every mistake in it is avoidable with a list: naming a number first, anchoring on your current salary, accepting on the call, and negotiating only base pay when the package is where the movement usually is.

The two numbers to decide in advance are a walk-away and a target, written down. Deciding either under pressure during the conversation is how people accept an offer they then resent.

  • Separates preparation, the package, the conversation and asking internally
  • Insists on three independent sources, since one is an anecdote
  • Treats pension, leave and flexibility as negotiable, which is where bands allow movement
  • Names the three mechanics: let them go first, stop talking, never accept on the call
  • Editable and exportable as PDF, CSV, Markdown or a Google Form
Read the guide: Why Checklists Work, and How to Use One Properly

Updated

How to use the Salary Negotiation Checklist

  1. Gather three independent sources on the range, and check whether a posted range is required where you are.
  2. Write down three or four delivered results with numbers, then set a walk-away and a higher target.
  3. List everything with value in the package, and prepare a second ask for when salary cannot move.
  4. Let them name a number first; if asked, give a researched range with your target near the bottom.
  5. Say your number, give the reason, stop talking, and never accept on the call.

Worked examples

Offer expected this week

Input

Research section

Output

Range researched, walk-away and target written down

Both decided calmly rather than under pressure.

Band cannot move

Input

Package section

Output

Second ask ready: leave, flexibility, review date, title

These usually cost the employer nothing.

Asking for a raise

Input

Internal section

Output

Asked before the budget cycle closes, with a specific figure

After the cycle there is nothing left to allocate.

Background and insight

Research needs to be plural. Three independent sources on the range for this role and location, published salary surveys, adverts that state ranges, and people actually doing the job, because one source is an anecdote. A growing number of jurisdictions require a posted range, which hands you the number for free. And knowing the internal band matters, because bands are often more rigid than recruiters imply and the ceiling changes what is worth asking for.

The package, not the salary, is where offers differ. Two offers with identical base pay can differ substantially once employer pension contribution, bonus terms, equity and leave are counted, and a few percentage points of pension contribution outweighs a modest salary difference over any real period. Flexibility, days at home and a start date often cost the employer nothing, which makes them the easiest things to win and the right second ask when a band genuinely cannot move.

Three mechanics do most of the work in the conversation itself. Let them name a figure or a range first where you can; where asked for expectations, give a researched range with your target near the bottom rather than a single number. Avoid anchoring on your current salary, and note that asking for salary history is unlawful in several places. And after stating your number and a one-line reason, stop talking: filling the silence is where people negotiate against themselves.

Never accepting on the call is the cheapest discipline available. "Thank you, that is very positive, may I come back to you tomorrow?" costs nothing, because nobody withdraws an offer over a day, and it converts an emotional decision into a considered one. Then get the full offer in writing before accepting or resigning.

Asking for a raise internally runs on different rules. Timing matters most, because decisions are usually made weeks before they are announced and there is genuinely nothing to allocate afterwards. The case should be about scope and results rather than need. And if the answer is no, asking what would make it a yes and by when turns a refusal into either a plan or useful information about where you work.

Common use cases

  • A new job offer

    The preparation and the three mechanics that do most of the work.

  • Comparing two offers

    Total package rather than base pay, with pension counted properly.

  • Asking for a raise

    Timing, the case to make, and what to do with a no.

  • A first negotiation

    Concrete scripts for the moments people find hardest.

Tips and limitations

  • Your target is not your minimum, and the first number you say should never be your minimum.
  • Compare employer pension contributions explicitly; a few points beats a modest salary gap.
  • Have a second ask ready. Bands are often rigid; leave and flexibility rarely are.
  • Stay warm throughout. You may well work for this person.
  • If the answer is no, ask what would make it a yes and by when, then diarise that date.

Sources and further reading

  1. Pay and wages, Acas. Pay, deductions and contractual terms
  2. Equal Pay and Compensation Discrimination, US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. Pay discrimination and salary history
  3. Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Published wage data by occupation and area

Frequently asked questions

Should I give my salary expectations first?

Let them name a figure or range first where you can. If you are asked directly, give a researched range with your target near the bottom of it rather than a single number, and avoid anchoring on your current salary, which in several places they are not allowed to ask about.

What should I ask for if the salary cannot move?

A signing amount, extra leave, a training budget, flexibility or days at home, an earlier review date, or a title change. Bands are often genuinely rigid while these cost the employer little, which makes them the easiest things to win.

Is it acceptable not to accept an offer immediately?

Yes, and you should not. "Thank you, that is very positive, may I come back to you tomorrow?" is normal and nobody withdraws an offer over a day. It converts an emotional decision into a considered one, and gives you time to get it in writing.

How do I compare two offers properly?

Add up everything with value: base pay, bonus terms, equity, employer pension contribution, leave and allowances. Pension contribution in particular can outweigh a modest salary difference, and two offers with the same headline salary can be meaningfully different.

When should I ask for a raise?

Before the budget cycle closes, because decisions are usually made weeks before they are announced and afterwards there is nothing to allocate. Make the case about scope and results with numbers rather than about need, and state a specific figure.

Is there an in-depth guide to the Salary Negotiation Checklist?

Yes. “Why Checklists Work, and How to Use One Properly” covers the background, how it works, common pitfalls and worked examples. Read the full guide.