Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler Running Costs in the UK

Compare an air source heat pump with a gas or oil boiler at price-cap rates, see why the SCOP decides it, and what the £7,500 Boiler Upgrade Scheme does to payback.

By · · 11 min read

Illustration for the Heat Pump Savings Calculator guide

United Kingdom edition. UK edition in pounds and kWh, built on Ofgem's October to December 2026 price cap, the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant and oil and LPG top-up, and gas boilers rather than furnaces. US edition

On flat price-cap rates, a UK heat pump only just beats a gas boiler, and a poorly designed one costs more. From 1 October to 31 December 2026 the GB average cap is 26.32p per kWh for electricity and 7.97p for gas, so electricity costs 3.3 times as much per kWh. A heat pump with a seasonal efficiency (SCOP) of 3 delivers heat at 8.8p per kWh; an 85% efficient gas boiler delivers it at 9.4p. The saving for a typical gas-heated home is about £59 a year. What turns a heat pump into a clear saving is a higher SCOP, a cheaper electricity rate, or replacing something worse than a modern gas boiler.

This edition does the sums with the UK Heat Pump Savings Calculator, starting from the kWh figure on your gas statement. It explains running costs, not a recommendation for your home; an MCS installer's heat loss survey is what tells you the SCOP your house can actually reach.

The one ratio that decides it

Compare what one kWh of heat costs from each system:

boiler: gas price / boiler efficiency heat pump: electricity price / SCOP

The heat pump is cheaper to run whenever the electricity-to-gas price ratio is below SCOP divided by boiler efficiency. With an 85% boiler and a SCOP of 3, that threshold is 3.53. The October to December 2026 cap ratio is 26.32 / 7.97 = 3.30, so the heat pump wins, narrowly.

Ofgem's price cap page gives those GB averages for Direct Debit customers, and notes that there is no VAT on electricity from 1 October 2026 to 31 March 2027, while the gas rate includes it. Rates vary by region and change every quarter, so use your own tariff.

Bar chart of the cost of a kWh of heat: old 75% gas boiler 10.6p, heat pump SCOP 2.5 10.5p, 85% gas boiler 9.4p, heat pump SCOP 3 8.8p, SCOP 3.5 7.5p, oil boiler 7.1p, SCOP 4 6.6p, and SCOP 3.5 on a 15p average rate 4.3p
Bar chart of the cost of a kWh of heat: old 75% gas boiler 10.6p, heat pump SCOP 2.5 10.5p, 85% gas boiler 9.4p, heat pump SCOP 3 8.8p, SCOP 3.5 7.5p, oil boiler 7.1p, SCOP 4 6.6p, and SCOP 3.5 on a 15p average rate 4.3p

A worked example from a gas statement

Your annual gas statement gives kWh. Take a home that uses 11,500 kWh of gas a year for heating and hot water, with an 85% efficient condensing boiler. Enter in the UK Heat Pump Savings Calculator: mains gas, 11,500 kWh, 85%, 7.97p, SCOP 3.0, 26.32p, an installed price of £13,000 and the £7,500 grant.

  • Heat the home needs: 11,500 x 0.85 = 9,775 kWh.
  • Electricity for the heat pump: 9,775 / 3 = 3,258 kWh.
  • Gas cost: £917 a year. Heat pump cost: £858. Saving: £59 a year.
  • Break-even: the heat pump stays cheaper while electricity is below 28.1p per kWh at this gas price.
  • Payback on the £5,500 after the grant: about 93 years at this saving, which is to say, not on running costs alone.

That last line is the honest headline for a modern gas boiler on a flat tariff. Now change one thing at a time:

ChangeHeat pump costSaving a yearPayback on £5,500
None (SCOP 3.0, 26.32p)£858£5993 years
SCOP 2.5, a system run hot£1,029£113 morenever
SCOP 3.5, low flow temperature£735£18130 years
SCOP 4.0£643£27320 years
SCOP 3.5 and a 15p average rate£419£49811.1 years
Old 75% boiler, SCOP 3.0£757£16034 years

Two lessons. First, SCOP matters as much as the tariff. Heat pumps are most efficient at low flow temperatures, which can mean larger radiators and a design based on a room-by-room heat loss calculation, not the old boiler's radiators run hot. Ask installers for the design SCOP at your design flow temperature. Second, the rate you pay matters. The 15p row is an illustration of an average rate, not a quoted tariff; heat pump and time-of-use tariffs vary, so put in what you would actually pay across a winter, including the expensive hours.

The Boiler Upgrade Scheme

GOV.UK's Boiler Upgrade Scheme is open in England and Wales and pays towards replacing a fossil fuel heating system, which it defines as oil, gas, electric or LPG. The grant amounts are:

  • £7,500 for an air source (air-to-water) or ground source heat pump;
  • £2,500 for an air-to-air heat pump;
  • £5,000 for a biomass boiler;
  • an extra £1,500 towards an air source or ground source heat pump until March 2027, if the home is heated by oil or LPG and has no mains gas connection.

Hybrid systems, such as a gas boiler with a heat pump, are not eligible, and you must own the property. Scotland has its own support, and the Northern Ireland scheme is closed. Enter the grant in the calculator's incentive box and the payback uses the cost after it.

Off the gas grid: oil and LPG

Off-gas homes are where the top-up applies, but the running-cost case is not automatic. With 2,000 litres of kerosene a year at 65p a litre in an 85% boiler, heat costs about 7.1p per kWh, cheaper than a SCOP 3 heat pump on flat cap rates at 8.8p:

  • Oil: £1,300 a year. Heat pump at SCOP 3.0: £1,599, so £299 a year more.
  • At SCOP 3.5 the gap narrows to £71 a year.
  • Emissions on the calculator's DESNZ 2026 grid factor fall from about 5.4 tonnes of CO2e to 0.8 tonnes.

Oil prices move a lot, so enter what you paid for your last fill. At these numbers the switch is a carbon decision first, unless a cheaper electricity rate is part of the plan.

Standing charges and hot water

The calculator compares unit costs only. Two adjustments are worth making yourself:

  1. The gas standing charge. If the heat pump lets you cap the gas supply altogether, including the hob, you stop paying the gas standing charge: 29.68p a day on the October to December 2026 cap, about £108 a year. Add that to the saving. If you keep gas for cooking, you keep paying it.
  2. Hot water. If the heat pump will also heat a hot water cylinder, include hot water in the gas kWh you enter. Subtract summer gas use only if the heat pump will not take over hot water.

With the standing charge counted, the first example's saving rises from £59 to about £167 a year.

Tools for this job

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas boiler in the UK?

Only just, on flat price-cap rates. With electricity at 26.32p and gas at 7.97p, a SCOP 3 heat pump delivers heat at 8.8p per kWh against 9.4p from an 85% gas boiler. A SCOP of 3.5 or better, or a cheaper electricity rate, widens the gap; a system run at high flow temperatures can cost more than gas.

What SCOP do I need to beat gas?

Divide your electricity rate by your gas rate and multiply by your boiler efficiency. On the October to December 2026 cap that is 3.30 x 0.85, so a SCOP above about 2.8 is cheaper to run than an 85% gas boiler. An older, less efficient boiler lowers the bar.

How much is the Boiler Upgrade Scheme grant?

£7,500 for an air source or ground source heat pump in England and Wales, £2,500 for an air-to-air heat pump and £5,000 for a biomass boiler. Homes heated by oil or LPG with no mains gas can get an extra £1,500 towards an air source or ground source heat pump until March 2027.

Will I save the gas standing charge with a heat pump?

Only if you remove gas completely, including for cooking. The gas standing charge on the October to December 2026 cap is 29.68p a day, about £108 a year, which in the worked example is most of the total saving.

Sources and further reading

Open the Heat Pump Savings Calculator

More Energy & Sustainability

Every tool in the Energy & Sustainability section, free and in your browser.