Founder Dilution and the ESOP Pool for an Australian Pty Ltd

How a Pty Ltd cap table moves through an angel pre-seed and a VC seed in A$, what the ESOP top-up costs, and the 20 investor, $2 million and 50 shareholder limits.

By · · 10 min read

Illustration for the Cap Table and Dilution Calculator guide

Australia edition. Written for Australian founders: Australian dollars, an angel pre-seed and a VC-led seed, the ESOP pool shuffle, and the Corporations Act limits a proprietary company meets first (20 investors and $2 million a year in personal offers, 50 non-employee shareholders). US edition

Two Australian founders who start at 45% each, raise a A$900,000 angel pre-seed at A$4 million pre-money and a A$3.5 million seed at A$14 million pre, both with an ESOP top-up, end with 26.14% each. A$1,229,523 of the seed's A$14 million headline pays for new ESOP shares, so the effective pre-money is A$12,770,477. The Australian version of the Cap Table Calculator opens on exactly this path. This guide follows each round with the tool's numbers, prices the pool shuffle with the Australian Option Pool Shuffle Calculator, and then checks the round against the Corporations Act limits that an Australian Pty Ltd runs into well before a Series A.

The starting cap table

The founders hold 4,500,000 ordinary shares each and reserve 1,000,000 shares for an ESOP pool. Investors price an Australian company on a fully diluted basis like anywhere else: issued shares, options granted and the unallocated pool all count.

HolderSharesFully diluted
Founder A4,500,00045.00%
Founder B4,500,00045.00%
ESOP pool (unallocated)1,000,00010.00%
Total10,000,000100.00%

The pre-seed: angels on personal offers

A group of angels puts in A$900,000 at a A$4,000,000 pre-money and asks for the pool to be 10% after the round. The existing 1,000,000 shares would be only 7.96% of the post-round total, so 256,410 new pool shares are created inside the pre-money. The price is A$4,000,000 ÷ 10,256,410 = A$0.3900 a share, and the angels receive 2,307,692 shares.

HolderSharesFully diluted
Founder A4,500,00035.82%
Founder B4,500,00035.82%
ESOP pool (unallocated)1,256,41010.00%
Angels2,307,69218.37%
Total12,564,103100.00%

The angels own their A$900,000 of a A$4.9 million post-money, 18.37%. The A$100,000 of new pool shares came out of the founders: the effective pre-money is A$3,900,000.

The seed and the ESOP shuffle

Before the seed the company grants 400,000 options to its first hires, leaving 856,410 unallocated. A seed VC then invests A$3,000,000 and the angels A$500,000 more at a A$14,000,000 pre-money, with an ESOP pool of 12% after the round, in the pre-money. The calculator needs 1,209,653 new pool shares, sets the price at A$1.0164 and issues 3,443,439 new shares:

HolderSharesFully diluted
Founder A4,500,00026.14%
Founder B4,500,00026.14%
ESOP pool (unallocated)2,066,06312.00%
Options granted400,0002.32%
Angels (both rounds)2,799,61216.26%
Seed VC2,951,51917.14%
Total17,217,195100.00%
Stacked bars of fully diluted ownership. Before the pre-seed: founders 45.00% each and a 10.00% ESOP pool on 10,000,000 shares. After the pre-seed: founders 35.82% each, pool 10.00%, angels 18.37% on 12,564,103 shares. After the seed: founders 26.14% each, pool 12.00%, angels 16.26%, options 2.32%, seed VC 17.14% on 17,217,195 shares
Stacked bars of fully diluted ownership. Before the pre-seed: founders 45.00% each and a 10.00% ESOP pool on 10,000,000 shares. After the pre-seed: founders 35.82% each, pool 10.00%, angels 18.37% on 12,564,103 shares. After the seed: founders 26.14% each, pool 12.00%, angels 16.26%, options 2.32%, seed VC 17.14% on 17,217,195 shares

Run the seed through the Option Pool Shuffle Calculator (12,564,103 shares before the round, 856,410 unallocated, 12% target) and the cost of the pool separates out:

  • Effective pre-money: A$14,000,000 less the new pool shares at A$1.0164 (A$1,229,523) = A$12,770,477.
  • Pre-money excluding the whole pool: A$11,900,000. The whole 12% pool is worth A$2,100,000, 12% of the A$17.5 million post-money.
  • Shuffle cost: existing holders keep 68.00% with the pool in the pre-money against 69.38% if it were added after the round, 1.38 points.
  • Counter-offer: a headline of A$15,301,948 with the same pool would leave the existing shares priced at a real A$14 million.

Each founder has given up 41.92% of the starting stake, but the value of each founder's 4,500,000 shares has gone from A$1,755,000 at the pre-seed price to A$4,573,916 at the seed price.

The Corporations Act checks

20 investors and A$2 million a year in personal offers

A small company raising from people it knows can do so without a prospectus under the personal offer exemption in section 708(1) to (3) of the Corporations Act: offers need no disclosure document if they do not take the number of people issued securities above 20 in any 12 months, or the amount raised above $2 million in any 12 months.

Not every investor counts. Section 708(8) covers sophisticated investors: a minimum amount payable on acceptance of at least $500,000, a person whose new and earlier payments for the same class add up to at least $500,000, or a person with a qualified accountant's certificate from the last six months that they meet the net asset or gross income test. Offers under the employee share scheme provisions are disregarded too.

Apply that to the example. If both rounds closed within 12 months and 14 angels took part, the personal offers are 14 people and A$1,400,000 (A$900,000 plus A$500,000), inside both ceilings. The VC's A$3,000,000 is at least $500,000, so it is a sophisticated investor offer and is left out of the count. Had the angels put in A$2.1 million across the two rounds, the company would need another exemption or a disclosure document. The calculator combines investors with the same name, so list each angel separately if you want the head count from the table.

No more than 50 non-employee shareholders

Section 113 says a company must have no more than 50 non-employee shareholders to be or stay a proprietary company. Employees, and former employees who became shareholders while employed, do not count, and joint holders of one parcel count as one. A long tail of small angels can reach 50 faster than founders expect. Shareholders who came in through a crowd-sourced funding (CSF) offer are not counted (section 113(2)(c)). Employees who exercise while still employed do not add to the count; a former employee who exercises after leaving does.

Grants from the pool and the start-up concession

Options from the ESOP pool can qualify for the employee share scheme start-up concession in the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. For an option, the concession needs, among other things, an exercise price of at least the market value of an ordinary share at grant (which may be below the investors' price for their class), a company with no listed equity that was incorporated less than 10 years before, aggregated turnover of A$50 million or less, and an Australian resident employer (section 83A-33), plus the 3-year minimum holding period and the 10% limit on shareholding and voting power in section 83A-45. A$1.0164 is the price of the seed's new shares; agree the ordinary share value with your adviser before setting exercise prices.

This is planning arithmetic, not legal or financial advice. Have a lawyer confirm which fundraising exemption each investor falls under before you issue shares.

Tools for this job

The US edition of this guide covers post-money SAFEs, and the co-founder equity split guide covers the split you start from.

Frequently asked questions

How many shareholders can a Pty Ltd have?

No more than 50 non-employee shareholders under section 113 of the Corporations Act. Employee shareholders, including people who became shareholders while employees, do not count, and joint holders of a parcel count as one.

What is the 20 investor and $2 million rule?

Under section 708(1) to (3), personal offers need no disclosure document while they do not take the number of investors above 20, or the amount raised above $2 million, in any 12 months. Sophisticated investor and employee share scheme offers are left out of the count.

Does a VC investing A$3 million count towards the 20 investors?

Not if its subscription is at least $500,000. That makes it a sophisticated investor offer under section 708(8), disregarded for the small scale offering count.

What does the ESOP top-up cost at the seed?

In the example, 1,209,653 new pool shares worth A$1,229,523 sit inside the A$14 million pre-money. Existing holders keep 68.00% instead of 69.38% with the pool added after the round.

Sources and further reading

  • Corporations Act 2001, Federal Register of Legislation. Section 113 (50 non-employee shareholders, CSF shareholders not counted) and section 708 (personal offers, the 20 investor and $2 million ceilings, sophisticated investors).
  • Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, Federal Register of Legislation. Division 83A, including the start-up concession for employee share schemes (sections 83A-33 and 83A-45).
  • The Option Pool Shuffle, Venture Hacks. The article that named the shuffle.
  • Term Sheet: Price, Brad Feld. How the pool lowers the true pre-money.
  • NVCA 2020 Term Sheet, National Venture Capital Association. The model wording that puts the pool in the pre-money.
  • Post-Money SAFE User Guide, Y Combinator. A worked Series A with the pool in the pre-money.

Open the Cap Table and Dilution Calculator

More Fundraising & Equity

Every tool in the Fundraising & Equity section, free and in your browser.