Column Buckling to CSA S16: Euler Load to Cr for HSS Columns

From the Euler load to the CSA S16 factored compressive resistance Cr: λ, the n = 1.34 and 2.24 curves for Class C and Class H HSS, and the CISC worked example.

By · · 11 min read

Illustration for the Column Buckling Calculator guide

Canada edition. Canadian edition built on CSA S16 clause 13.3.1 (n = 1.34 or 2.24), CSA G40.21 350W HSS in Class C and Class H, and the Canadian Institute of Steel Construction's worked example. US edition

A steel column in Canada is designed to CSA S16, and the number that goes on the calculation is the factored compressive resistance Cr from clause 13.3.1, not the Euler load. Euler's formula is still the first step, because it gives the elastic buckling stress Fe that sets the slenderness parameter λ. S16 then reduces the squash load with a single formula whose exponent n depends on how the section was made. For the Canadian Institute of Steel Construction's own example, an HSS 203 × 203 × 6.4 Class C in 350W steel over 4.8 m, the Euler load is 2,680 kN and Cr is 1,112 kN.

This edition follows that chain with the Column Buckling Calculator (CSA S16), which shows Fe, λ, n, Cr/A and Cr and reproduces the CISC example. The American version of this article, built on AISC 360, is here.

Where S16 sits in the building code

The National Building Code of Canada, Part 4, calls up CSA S16 for structural steel, and the provincial codes adopt it the same way. The British Columbia Building Code, for instance, says in Article 4.3.4.1 that buildings and structural members made of structural steel shall conform to CSA S16. Check which edition of S16 your province's current code references, since the factors below have been stable but clause numbers can move between editions.

Step 1: Euler's elastic buckling stress

For a pin-ended column:

Fe = π² E / (KL / r)²

S16 uses E = 200,000 MPa. For the CISC example, A = 4,900 mm² and r = 79.9 mm, so I = A r² = 3,128 cm⁴. Over KL = 4,800 mm:

  1. KL/r = 4,800 / 79.9 = 60.1.
  2. Fe = π² × 200,000 / 60.1² = 546.9 MPa.
  3. Euler load = 546.9 × 4,900 = 2,680 kN.

Fe is far above the 350 MPa yield stress. A column that stocky would yield long before it buckled elastically, which is why Euler alone overstates its capacity.

Step 2: effective length

The K factor converts actual length to effective length. Theoretical values are 0.5 (both ends fixed), 0.7 (fixed and pinned), 1.0 (pinned) and 2.0 (flagpole). In practice, columns in braced frames are usually designed with K = 1.0, because real end connections rarely give the full theoretical fixity. Columns in sway frames need K above 1.0, or a second-order analysis with notional loads under S16's stability requirements.

Bracing is the cheapest way to add capacity. Using K = 0.8 on the CISC column (KL/r = 48.1) raises Cr from 1,113 to 1,267 kN; adding a brace that halves the unbraced length does much more.

Step 3: λ and the S16 resistance formula

λ  = √(Fy / Fe)
Cr = φ A Fy (1 + λ²ⁿ)^(−1/n)

where φ is the resistance factor for steel that S16 sets; take its value from the standard. The calculator applies it, and its result for this column matches CISC's tabulated 227 MPa (below). For the example, λ = √(350 / 546.9) = 0.80.

The exponent n captures residual stress and initial crookedness:

nApplies to (CISC tables)
1.34Hot-rolled and fabricated shapes; HSS to CSA G40.21 Class C (cold-formed non-stress-relieved), ASTM A500 or ASTM A1085 (Table 4-3)
2.24HSS to CSA G40.21 Class H (hot-formed, or cold-formed stress-relieved) and doubly symmetric welded three-plate members with oxy-flame-cut flange edges (Table 4-4)

A higher n gives a curve that stays closer to Fy at moderate slenderness, because those sections carry less residual stress.

Stress against slenderness ratio KL/r for 350W steel: the Euler hyperbola for E 200 GPa and the CSA S16 unit factored resistance Cr/A for Class H HSS with n 2.24 and Class C HSS with n 1.34, with the HSS 203 by 203 by 6.4 over 4.8 m plotted on the Class C curve at 227 MPa
Stress against slenderness ratio KL/r for 350W steel: the Euler hyperbola for E 200 GPa and the CSA S16 unit factored resistance Cr/A for Class H HSS with n 2.24 and Class C HSS with n 1.34, with the HSS 203 by 203 by 6.4 over 4.8 m plotted on the Class C curve at 227 MPa

Worked example: the CISC column, Class C and Class H

Enter I = 3,128 cm⁴ and A = 49.0 cm² directly, K = 1.0, L = 4.8 m, Fy = 350 MPa, E = 200 GPa, code CSA S16:

Class C (n = 1.34)Class H (n = 2.24)
KL/r60.160.1
λ0.800.80
Cr/A227.1 MPa273.9 MPa
Cr1,113 kN1,342 kN

CISC's Table 4-3 gives Cr/A = 227 MPa and Cr = 227 × 4,900 = 1,112 kN; the calculator's 1,113 kN differs only by rounding. Ordering the same size in Class H gives 21% more resistance. On a drawing, "HSS 203×203×6.4" says nothing about the class, so specify it, and check the mill certificate before substituting.

The Euler load of 2,680 kN is 2.4 times Cr. Treating Euler as a design value would be badly unconservative.

How length erodes Cr

The same HSS 203 × 203 × 6.4 Class C, pinned, at increasing lengths:

LKL/rCr
4.8 m60.11,113 kN
6.0 m75.1920 kN
8.0 m100.1654 kN
12.0 m150.2346 kN
16.0 m200.3206 kN

At 6.0 m the Class H version still gives 1,133 kN, about the same as the Class C column at 4.8 m. At 16 m the column has passed a KL/r of 200, beyond the range of CISC's unit-resistance tables (KL/r 1 to 200). Check the slenderness limit in S16 itself before relying on a member this slender.

A smaller column: HSS 102 × 102 × 6.4

A common post size for canopies, mezzanines and storage racks. Taking a sharp-cornered section (A ≈ 2,419 mm², r = 38.97 mm) over 3 m, pinned, KL/r = 77.0:

  • Class C: Cr = 443 kN.
  • Class H: Cr = 545 kN.

Published HSS tables give a slightly smaller area because of the rounded corners, so use the tabulated A and r for the final check by choosing "Enter I and A directly".

Common mistakes

  • Using E = 210 GPa from a European reference. S16 uses 200,000 MPa.
  • Applying φ twice. The resistance factor is built into Cr; adding another safety factor double-counts.
  • Assuming Class H when the supplier ships Class C. Class C is the usual cold-formed product, so design for it unless Class H is specified and confirmed.
  • Checking only one axis of a W-shape. W columns usually buckle about the weak axis unless it is braced at closer spacing.
  • Ignoring slender walls. HSS with high width-to-thickness ratios are Class 4 and need a reduced effective area.
  • Ignoring bending. Eccentric beam connections and lateral load make the member a beam-column, checked with S16's interaction equations.

Tools for this job

These calculations are for preliminary sizing. Columns support everything above them, so the final design should be sealed by a professional engineer licensed in your province, to CSA S16 and the building code that applies.

Frequently asked questions

What is the CSA S16 formula for compressive resistance?

Cr = φ A Fy (1 + λ²ⁿ)^(−1/n), with φ the S16 resistance factor, λ = √(Fy / Fe), Fe = π² E / (KL/r)² and n = 1.34 or 2.24. For an HSS 203 × 203 × 6.4 Class C over 4.8 m in 350W, Cr = 1,112 kN.

When do I use n = 2.24 instead of 1.34?

For HSS made to CSA G40.21 Class H and for doubly symmetric welded three-plate members with flame-cut flange edges (CISC Table 4-4). Hot-rolled shapes and Class C, A500 or A1085 HSS use n = 1.34 (Table 4-3).

What is the maximum slenderness ratio for a steel column in Canada?

CISC's unit-resistance tables for S16 cover KL/r from 1 to 200. Check the slenderness limit for compression members in CSA S16 itself.

Why is Cr so much lower than the Euler load?

Euler assumes a perfectly straight, centrally loaded column with no residual stress. S16's curve reflects tests on real members, and the resistance factor φ reduces it further. For the CISC example Cr is about 42% of the Euler load.

Sources and further reading

Open the Column Buckling Calculator

More Civil & Structural

Every tool in the Civil & Structural section, free and in your browser.